Re:Show HN: Puree – Password-based Uniform-Random-Equivalent...
by Thorrez on Monday June 08, 2020 @02:06AM
(#23454029)
>there’s definitely ways to retrieve past writes from a hard drive.
Please provide some evidence.
> You think just zero writing it out once is enough?
I definitely think a single zero write on a disk drive is enough (or at least that it's as good as 3 writes or 100 writes). There's no evidence anyone has ever recovered a file that was overwritten by zeros a single time on any hard disk drive from the last 20 years.
I might have to run my own Great Zero Challenge v2.
> Why do you think DoD standards call for no less than 3 writes when erasing a drive?
I think you're referring to an old DoD standard. Prior to 2007 the DoD recommended that. Now they don't recommend that, and only recommend degaussing or destruction of the drive.
Please provide some evidence.
> You think just zero writing it out once is enough?
I definitely think a single zero write on a disk drive is enough (or at least that it's as good as 3 writes or 100 writes). There's no evidence anyone has ever recovered a file that was overwritten by zeros a single time on any hard disk drive from the last 20 years.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_remanence#Feasibility_of_...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=511568
Hmm, it looks like the site is down now. Well, here's a copy of the content:
https://www.techpowerup.com/forums/threads/the-great-zero-ch...
I might have to run my own Great Zero Challenge v2.
> Why do you think DoD standards call for no less than 3 writes when erasing a drive?
I think you're referring to an old DoD standard. Prior to 2007 the DoD recommended that. Now they don't recommend that, and only recommend degaussing or destruction of the drive.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_remanence#Standards
Old one:
https://it.ouhsc.edu/policies/documents/infosecurity/DoD_522...
New one:
https://files.meetup.com/7887332/107-009-005_Exhibit_B.pdf