Re:It's still unclear whether having Flash is better than no...
by tptacek on Saturday March 19, 2011 @06:09PM
(#2344883)
CSS3 is also worthy of concern. It's true that the security concern is different, and it's true that the security concerns are in general cumulative, but it's not like you can decisively say "things that add to the attack surface are bad".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:It's still unclear whether having Flash is better than no...
by trotsky on Saturday March 19, 2011 @06:57PM
(#2344980)
I think it's pretty safe to say that Adobe code bases have more or less earned themselves a special line item in the security concerns list at this point.
Re:It's still unclear whether having Flash is better than no...
by tptacek on Saturday March 19, 2011 @07:03PM
(#2344996)
You could --- and I'm not just saying this to be argumentative --- say the same thing about parts of Webkit.
I want to be clear that I agree that Flash adds more than a banana-equivalent dose of insecurity. I just worry about the notion that the rest of the system is much better.
Re:It's still unclear whether having Flash is better than no...
by ZeroGravitas on Sunday March 20, 2011 @07:49AM
(#2346054)
I'd argue the same could be said for the functionality of Flash. Yes, watching video via Flash can start the fans flying, particularly on OS X before Apple allowed them access to the hardware. But, it's not like displaying highly encoded H.264 and allowing people to manipulate the resulting output is easy. The last comparison I saw showed only IE9 convincingly beating Flash in this task, and the big outliers were some of the browsers like Safari on Windows which was abysmal, whereas Flash was solidly good across platforms and browsers. And I'm guessing that performance in other areas is a clearer win for Flash.
I have ideological reasons for not liking Flash, but clearly my brand of ideology isn't as good at mass-mind control and reality-re-defining as the Apple-ideologues. I'll be glad to see it go, I just wish it was because people thought that core web technologies should be open with multiple interoperable implementations, rather than because of a concerted campaign of misinformation and misdirection about performance.
Re:It's still unclear whether having Flash is better than no...
by tptacek on Sunday March 20, 2011 @11:34AM
(#2346458)
I think you may have accidentally replied to the wrong comment.
Re:It's still unclear whether having Flash is better than no...
by ZeroGravitas on Sunday March 20, 2011 @01:43PM
(#2346811)
Your point appeared to be that Flash is insecure, but that the things proposed to replace it e.g. Webkit, CSS3 implementations suffer from similar issues. My point was that, similarly, its performance problems with video are shared by other browsers when implementing the same functionality.