News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by the_mitsuhiko on Sunday June 07, 2020 @11:36AM (#23448108)
I strongly encourage developments like that. It’s a shame that Linux and macOS didn’t adopt something like Microsoft’s symbol server. This project could become something like this.

If you have an installation like this you can also plug it into Sentry as symbol server and it picks it up.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by bmn__ on Sunday June 07, 2020 @03:41PM (#23450094)
"Good enough" solutions were already in place for many years, that's why a symbol server was not a matter of urgency. Did you know about the following?

• A package manager can be configured to install the corresponding debuginfo/debugsource packages, this is literally one menu toggle. It's off by default to save disk space, as most users don't need them.

• A desktop environment crash handler (e.g. drkonqi) offers to install the missing debuginfo/debugsource packages and then produces a complete stacktrace.

• gdb shows the command for installing the missing debuginfo/debugsource packages it needs.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by usr1106 on Sunday June 07, 2020 @09:49PM (#23452805)
In Opensuse (release, haven't used Tumbleweed) I found it easy to install debuginfo and debugsource packages.

In Ubuntu I found it slightly confusing to locate debug symbol packages. I understood (or misunderstood) that there are 2 options where to find debug symbols and it just depends on the package maintainer how it's done. I did not find how to install debugsource at all.

By doing debugsource I mean the source that has all the patches applied exactly as during the build and is in the same path as the symbols suggest.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by schultetwin1 on Sunday June 07, 2020 @05:25PM (#23450980)
I'm not aware of those solutions. Very cool! Are they specific to one distro (for example, Fedora)? How do I get gdb to show me the command to installing missing packages?

One downside to those solutions, they only support debugging on the same machine running the executable. If I want to debug a crash dump from a machine different from my own I might not be able to install the packages.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by bmn__ on Sunday June 07, 2020 @06:37PM (#23451609)
> Are they specific to one distro

no

> How do I get gdb to show me the command

With the "run" command. You get a message "Missing separate debuginfos, use:" and then debuginfo-install, zypper etc. depending on the distro.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by the_mitsuhiko on Monday June 08, 2020 @02:03AM (#23454013)
None of what we have is good enough unfortunately. If you have a random crash from a customer you’re out of luck.
Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by de_watcher on Monday June 08, 2020 @07:28AM (#23455620)
You load up the debug info and get all file/line info you need, or you debug the core file.
Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by NovemberWhiskey on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:36AM (#23456822)
With the Microsoft tooling, you debug a crash dump and your IDE automatically pulls in the symbol data from your symbol server and then automatically checks out the appropriate revisions from your config management system, because the references are embedded into the symbol files at build time.

It’s a much better mechanism than anything I’ve looked at in the Linux space (caveat: I have not been developing C++ for a while).

I was so impressed I started looking at what it would take to implement for the gcc/gdb toolchain but discovered Microsoft held a patent and gave up.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by saagarjha on Sunday June 07, 2020 @12:06PM (#23448319)
Apple runs something similar internally, as it can correlate debug symbols to binaries by checking the UUID the linker sticks in it. Unfortunately, it’s not generally available…
Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by pjscott on Sunday June 07, 2020 @09:21PM (#23452664)
There used to be a hack where you could write your own UUID-to-dSYM script, name it "dsymForUUID", and then lldb would assume it was Apple's internal magic thing and use it. Fortunately lldb seems to have improved since those days, and has less magical options available:

http://lldb.llvm.org/use/symbols.html

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by blinkingled on Sunday June 07, 2020 @11:50AM (#23448217)
Yep, in case of Linux the 'it's OSS. Download the tar.gz configure --enable-debug and deal with it' attitude hampered the development and use of something like a Symbol Server.

Microsoft has had it since at least 2005 - that's the first Visual Studio release I remember using it with - so it might have exited before that. It's things like these that separate MS from all others - Engineering culture of having to give 2 shits about other people - OEMs, developers, corporate IT, partners and having the chops to effectively address it at scale within their Engineering teams.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by de_watcher on Monday June 08, 2020 @07:31AM (#23455633)
What are you talking about? Linux distros come with debug info packages.
Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by blinkingled on Monday June 08, 2020 @09:56AM (#23456491)
Yeah I know - that's a more recent thing however and the attitude in the early days was what I was referring to.

Oh and the debuginfo packages used to be and still are huge in size. Not sure if anything has changed most recently but the concept of lazy loading symbols from remote and storing only what you need locally is not something you can do with debuginfo packages.

Re:Automatically download symbols and sources in GDB by de_watcher on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:35AM (#23456815)
Oh yes, the size is killing it. Our applications are not that big so the bandwidth use isn't completely insane, but I see the problem.