News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by kragen on Saturday March 19, 2011 @01:53PM (#2344221)
I think Marcin and his crew are doing fantastic work, and their simple, low-cost designs could make a real difference, especially in the case of places that are poorly served by current mass manufacturing.

One of my first kragen-tol posts http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/1998-Novembe... predicted mass adoption of this kind of thing within ten years. So far it's taking longer than I expected, although it's happened in a few niches: http://www.cleggind.com/specialstructures/mobilepartsmachine...

One thing that some may not appreciate is that a local micro-factory doesn't have to run cheaper than, say, GM's body panel stamping machines in order to be economically beneficial.

To be concrete, consider the case where you need a certain screw. The screw that holds the left wheel of your push lawnmower on, which fell out in the grass somewhere. It needs to be a countersunk head to fit, and it has a much narrower thread pitch than most screws that size. None of the hardware stores in your area carry any screws in the right diameter and thread pitch, let alone a countersunk head. What do you do?

Well, at the time, I lived in Dayton, Ohio, one of the machining centers of the world. So I went across town to a company that manufactured screws and spent about US$5 to buy a pound of the right kind of screw (I think it was about half an inch diameter and half an inch long, with a humongous countersunk head). Here in Buenos Aires, I imagine I'd just be screwed.

Now, I don't know what kind of process you use to manufacture a big machine screw like that. Do you cold-roll the threads, or do you cut them with a die from a cold-forged blank cut from bar stock, or what? I'm sure that, whatever it is, it isn't cutting it out on a lathe, or they'd be sold by the screw, not by the pound.

But you can cut one on a lathe, except for the slot in the head, of course. If my local hardware store had had a fully automatic CNC lathe and the appropriate software, they could have punched in the numbers and cut me the correct screw in about five minutes. Maybe it would cost me US$10, but it would have saved me hours of shopping and driving.

(I probably could also have mail-ordered it from McMaster-Carr, although that still leaves me without a lawnmower for a few days.)

Custom automated manufacturing isn't competing economically just with mass production, even for clearly mass-producible goods like machine screws. It's competing with mass production, plus the costs of its supply-chain management and its wholesale and retail channels, plus the delays implicit in the same.

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by noonespecial on Saturday March 19, 2011 @04:21PM (#2344622)
That's why I bough one of these:

http://www.harborfreight.com/7-inch-x-10-inch-precision-mini...

Now lets be clear, this is a horrible little heap of Chinese junk. Its about as rigid as wet toast, the gears are plastic and the motor is about as strong as a cordless drill. But it was $500 and I can pick it up and stash it under my workbench when I'm not using it. In short its not as bad as it was cheap.

The upside is that I get super powers.

I've made everything from car parts to pluming fixtures. I no longer even bother going in to the auto parts store or hardware store to be laughed at by the $7/hour flunky as they incredulously ask why I'd even want a part like the one I'm looking for. I just grab some round-stock and whip one up.

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by kragen on Saturday March 19, 2011 @04:34PM (#2344654)
That sounds really interesting! Do you have photos of some of the things you've done with it? I'd love to have more details.
Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by noonespecial on Saturday March 19, 2011 @04:59PM (#2344712)
I found out after I bought it that this design as been rolling out of china for nearly 20 years under hundreds of different names. There's a giant community built up around modifying this thing (and its cousin the mini-mill) in order to get decent results.

Start drinking from the firehose here:

http://www.mini-lathe.com/

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by nickpinkston on Saturday March 19, 2011 @02:22PM (#2344292)
Yea, I think yours is a more realistic view of the micro-factory concept. Screws are certainly made as cheap as they are because they use specialized equipment.

However, I'm unsure of how much tooling / material blanks your hardware store would need to have the ability to produce even a small subset of replacement parts.

It's probably going to happen more when 3D printing and similar tooling-free technologies become much more mature in there ability to make precision parts from a variety of materials. You can print a stainless nut sized / shaped object right now for about $10, but the quality isn't quite their yet - but give it time...

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by kragen on Saturday March 19, 2011 @04:32PM (#2344649)
I'm no machinist, but I think you can cut a pretty wide variety of shapes from a simple round steel or brass bar on a lathe.

Specialized raw materials are a problem, but I have the impression that a remarkably large fraction of everyday items could be cut out of a sort of general-use steel or brass with only a marginal increase in size. There are lots of different steels and brasses (and of course a huge variety of other materials) but you don't really need them for most things.

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by nickpinkston on Saturday March 19, 2011 @05:30PM (#2344787)
It's actually the opposite - even a mundane part like the lug bolt you describe will go through several hardening processes, and post-processing for corrosion resistance. If not, you're asking for a huge failure on a critical part. This is an easy example - it's amazing the diversity in processes and materials needed to manufacture products from base materials. 

Even in a ballpoint pen, there a good 5-10 dies needed to make the body and cartridge holder, pretty exotic processes to make the tip, a non-trivial pad-printing for color, and many other post-processing needs. Yes, we could reengineer products to not need this, but you're going to see increased costs and decreased performance - I.e. No one will buy it...

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by kragen on Saturday March 19, 2011 @10:10PM (#2345313)
I don't think the screw that held my lawnmower wheel on went through several hardening processes. It might have been heat-treated to strengthen it, but I think typically you don't harden machine screws. Corrosion resistance, sure, it might have been galvanized or something. (But I doubt it.) The lawnmower wheel falling off as I pushed the mower did not constitute a "huge failure."

I think I adequately addressed the "increased costs and decreased performance, so no one will buy it" objection in my original comment. :)

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by bigiain on Sunday March 20, 2011 @12:06AM (#2345494)
"It's actually the opposite - even a mundane part like the lug bolt you describe will go through several hardening processes, and post-processing for corrosion resistance. If not, you're asking for a huge failure on a critical part."

That's at least party due to the different design requirements and constraints that mass-produced for-profit engineers work under. That lawnmower wheel screw was specified not purely on the engineering requirements to "hold the wheel on", but on various other important-to-the-company-designing-them-for-sale requirements, probably including things like: use the cheapest fastener that we already keep in stock that'll do the job, use a fastener that will reliably last the length of the warranty period at the lowest cost, use a fastener that's compatible with out existing automated manufacturing tools. On top of that there will have been other decisions already made like "use an existing wheel assembly" and "ensure the mowers packaged size and weight fit in with existing supply chain logistics".

Once designers are freed from existing manufacturing industry constraints, I like to hope that one day we'll download a push-mower design from somewhere like Google Sketchup, where the designers were perfectly happy to "over engineer" critical components and where the design requirements might include ideas like "should last long enough to pass on to your grandchildren", and "will still be able to be repaired at the side of the road with a flatblade screwdriver and a rock".

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by nickpinkston on Sunday March 20, 2011 @12:20AM (#2345519)
If you're arguing against standardization in parts - that's an uphill battle - sure once we have replicators it doesn't matter, but that's futurism.

I'm actively fighting for open source hardware and standards, but a big part of this is finding off the shelf components - look at Http://octopart.com for a good example of what this looks like.

Re:Open Source Micro-Factory by bigiain on Sunday March 20, 2011 @03:35AM (#2345751)
"If you're arguing against standardization in parts"

Oh, very much not.

I'm more commenting on unnecessary overspecialisation instead.

Unnecessary for non-commercial applications anyway - I understand why Apple chooses to put difficult-to-use fasteners in their products, if for no other reason than to minimise fraudulent warrant claims, but there's a whole different set of motivations if designers are going to use the equivalent of "open source" for digitally reproducible home-fab ready "object" files.