News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit Is Down To One Developer by masklinn on Saturday March 19, 2011 @06:22AM (#2343291)
> If the filter were genuinely indicative of that, that would be great. However, my guess is that working there is quite different from doing makework puzzles for no pay (I hope, at least!).

The puzzles are in the links provided, why didn't you just go read them?

Re:Reddit Is Down To One Developer by davidw on Saturday March 19, 2011 @06:29AM (#2343294)
Because I have more interesting puzzles to work on: my own projects, many of which are available on the internet for potential clients or employers to look at should they wish to hire me.
Re:Reddit Is Down To One Developer by masklinn on Saturday March 19, 2011 @11:30AM (#2343799)
Let me recap:

* You have the time to post on HN strongly implying that these "puzzles" are likely not that great (they're not even puzzles to start with)

* You have the time to purposefully misread replies (I suggested that you go read them before judging them, not that you go work on them) and reply yourself

* But you don't have the time to click on a link and read 20 lines of text?

Re:Reddit Is Down To One Developer by davidw on Saturday March 19, 2011 @12:59PM (#2344060)
I actually had a look before, and they confirmed my impression that they're pretty much a waste of my time.

The point is not whether I clicked through or not, the point is whether I'm going to spend my free time on my own projects, or completely useless projects for some company - they're not even things the company needs!

I'm more than happy to be judged on the merits of what I've produced, both proprietary and open source, rather than fooling around with invented puzzles.

Re:Reddit Is Down To One Developer by mgkimsal on Saturday March 19, 2011 @09:22PM (#2345223)
If the tasks were things the company needed directly, they'd be accused of trying to get people to 'work for free'.
Re:Reddit Is Down To One Developer by raganwald on Saturday March 19, 2011 @02:15PM (#2344283)
This is the wonderful thing about Homininae. I also have lots of my own work and at this very minute I have a ton of outstanding issues to close on the Faux framework alone.

Nevertheless, programming puzzles are like catnip to me, so I don't mind solving them as part of a job interview process (or at least, I didn't mind the last time I was actually looking).

I would NEVER say that I have a superior strategy to you, or that you have a superior strategy, or that programming puzzles are an excellent filter, or a terrible one. Just that some people will like them, and some not.

You don't, that much is obvious. Or at least, you don't in the context of a job application. Fair enough, and nobody should ever suggest that (a) This is a bad idea on your part, or (b) on the basis of your anecdotal evidence, this is a bad idea on Reddit's part.