News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by MattGaiser on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:01PM (#23424622)
> where almost all human knowledge is available online for free

And it has been so for nearly 20 years and changed very little. MOOCs are a failure as people will not finish them. Online certificates carry no weight with employers even if people do.

We have promising prototypes of self driving trucks. We don't have such models for education.

Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by woofie11 on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:06PM (#23424663)
We have plenty of promising prototypes. The original MITx / 6.002x had in the nineties rate it as being as-good-as or better than in-person.

OLI before that had good prototypes too.

The low-quality junk came in scaling. Part of that had to do with culture and people (business people took over from academics). Part of that with economics (people didn't shop on quality). Part on difficulty training. Etc.

Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by MattGaiser on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:15PM (#23424731)
The problem is not in information quality. I agree that is a solved problem. But that was never the big challenge in education (besides the politics of it).

The problem is in getting students to complete the work, be honestly assessed about the work, get feedback on their work as well as for employers to believe that the assessment means anything.

Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by bradlys on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:30PM (#23424818)
> The problem is not in information quality.

Information quality can be interpreted many ways. I wouldn't say most teachers are good at their job or at presenting information. Most I had were not good at the job - a lot of them were babysitters and acted as such. At the college level, it's possibly worse where the people are so consumed with their research that they have absolutely no interest in teaching or getting good at it.

Textbooks are also very poor quality. History textbooks are probably the worst offenders.

Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by MattGaiser on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:33PM (#23424837)
I was mostly referring to why MITx isn't a solution to education.

I agree with respect to the current education system.

History is hard to correct as it is politically thorny and frequently disputed. If I built a e-learning system, I wouldn't include that.

Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by woofie11 on Sunday June 07, 2020 @01:31PM (#23448975)
Most of those are solved problems, technically. What's not solved are, as you put it "the politics of it." Business models don't align with good models. Markets are highly inefficient, timescales are long, and transparency is poor.

MITx became edX because of that misalignment.

Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by scollet on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:08PM (#23424677)
There are promising models around learning and plenty of resources but I think the incentive is underdeveloped. This is not mentioning economic and political factors, but from a technical standpoint, the means are there.
Re:US schools lay off hundreds of thousands by hckr_news on Friday June 05, 2020 @01:05AM (#23425252)
Not necessarily. MOOCs and the opportunity to access free and open education are widely consumed by people outside the US in emerging countries.