Re:Ask HN: Have you ever gone without a computer or phone fo...
by michaelt on Friday June 05, 2020 @08:52AM
(#23427897)
A self-consistent philosophy based on a world with a 99.5% lower population seems like a step backwards for that 99.5%, regardless of how good it is for the freedom and equality of the remaining 0.5% of the population?
I mean, in my mind that's right up there with negative utilitarianism's benevolent world-exploder in terms of clever ideas that aren't good ideas.
Re:Ask HN: Have you ever gone without a computer or phone fo...
by partomniscient on Friday June 05, 2020 @10:19AM
(#23428841)
Unfortunately sometimes the only way to find out that a clever idea is not a good idea is to test it via implementation.
Why shouldn't it be taken seriously when it's the only variety of anarchism that's actually self-consistent? You can't run a large, mass society on anarchist principles, because social organization on a large scale will always require some way of formally resolving disputes, and that pretty much implies that conventional politics and "rule" by some over others will be a thing.