I was not clear, i was speaking against the idea that lockdown did not save lives. Here is my case:
P1: We seems to be able to keep R0 around one (a bit under actually) when everyone is following social distancing.
C1: Following P1 if a country have 50 case a day, it will stay at 50 case until a vaccine is found as long as those social distancing rules are followed.
C1': Following P1 if a country have around 3000 case a day, it will stay at 3000 cases a day until a vaccine is found as long as those social distancing rules are followed.
P2: If natural immunity is achievable, then a vaccine will be found (this is a weak point, i have no argument for that, it is my poor understanding of immunobiology that tell me this as a correct premise, but my confidence index is barely 60%)
P2 corollary: If we can't find any vaccine, then no long-term natural immunity exist
P3: 50 cases a day is better than 3000 cases a day
C2: C1 + P2 Corollary + P3: In any case, having less cases when taking "normal" (aka no-lockdown) social distancing mesure will save lives. This number of cases is arbitrary and will change depending on the population and density of a country.
I'm not deciding policies here. I'm just saying that initial lockdown make sense before appropriate measure that will keep R0 low are taken (case tracking, quarantining, social distancing), and that "flatten the curve" is a good slogan but is not only to help the NHS, it will also decrease the number of total cases.
If I look at those, I see that the curve remains flattened after reopening, despite the fact that people are going out more often again. Doesn't this strengthen OP's case against a total economical lockdown?