News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debian Handbook for Debian 10 Buster by lmm on Thursday June 04, 2020 @07:44AM (#23415340)
> The ssh key vulnerability was as much a fault of the upstream as it was Debian: the Debian maintainer who made the patch explicitly asked the OpenSSL mailing list if it was okay, and they indicated at least acquiescence in the change.

IIRC they asked a list that was not the main project list and not intended for security-critical questions. Code that actually goes in to OpenSSL gets a lot more scrutiny from the OpenSSL side, and other big-name distributions either have dedicated security teams that review changes to security-critical packages, or don't modify upstream sources for them. Debian is both unusually aggressive in its patching (not just for OpenSSL; look at e.g. the cdrecord drama) and unusually lax in its security review.

> Given that upstream OpenSSL itself would have the Heartbleed bug revealed a decade later, with all the revelations of its source code quality made more notable as a result, I'm willing to place more blame on OpenSSL than Debian here.

Heartbleed was a much more "normal"/defensible bug IMO. Buffer overflows are a normal/expected part of using memory-unsafe languages; every major C/C++ project has had them. Not using random numbers to generate your cryptographic key is just hilariously awful.

There are no comments on this comment yet.