if by merit you mean competency in coding, and by years of experience you effectively mean years in coding, what you have stated here is directly in conflict with your requirements of 5 years of experience. nothing personal: them's the breaks.
admittedly, i get what you're trying to do - filter out bad candidates cheaply - but one ought to be able to introspect and see what they're saying (signaling) and what their actions show.
there are tons of very talented people leaving bootcamps, students out of colleges, etc. that are not going to every qualify, and may already be more sharp than some corporate drone with 5 years under his belt. hell, imagine all the first-job people with 1-2 years of experience who are hungry to level up their technical skills but can't get your job.
We already got lots of very poor candidates. I doubt removing the filters that we did have would have improved things.
Curious: what are you doing that you think 5 years' experience is necessary?
I presume those other things are not[0] gender and skin colour, so what else is relevant, you tell me.
[0] almost missed out the 'not'. That would have made for fun fireworks.