Re:On being startled by a programming language
by scott_s on Friday March 18, 2011 @10:21AM
(#2340456)
silentbicycle's examples and points have actually made me come around somewhat.
But there is a key difference between the terseness and density of APL-derived languages and the C implementation of the runtime: in the actual languages, the semantics of the language are well defined and enforced by the compiler. C is a free-for-all. So while there is discipline behind the C code - and I can see that it mimics the language it implements - it must be self discipline. That makes it more dangerous, and objecting to that is not the same as objecting to the APL family of languages themselves.
Let's note that the payoff for departing from the mainstream in this way is not small: these languages achieve abstractive (compositional) power and elegance without sacrificing efficiency. Those two things are incompatible in nearly every other programming context -- so much so that it's a truism that higher-level code is shorter but slower, lower-level code is faster but more verbose. Yet here they happily co-exist.