Thanks for the feedback on 11201. I anticipate issues like this in the data set.
Another example: 11202 shouldn't have a map at all, it's reserved for the central PO in Brooklyn (Cadman Plaza GPO), instead it's being drawn as a region in North Brooklyn.
Another example from outside Brooklyn: 60515 (Downers Grove, IL) looks accurate, but 60516 (southern Downers Grove) appears to be drawn using the 60517 (Woodridge, IL) boundaries, and when I punch in 60517 it gets drawn using the boundaries for 60561 (Darien, IL).
I haven't played with GIS data for several years but remember than there was a set of ZIP code data sets around 2005 which had accurate latitude/longitude points but the ZIP codes were frequently off by one (I ended up having to manually massage the data because I couldn't find a pattern to the way the ZIP code was appearing in the data).