Re:Policymakers must consider the harms of pandemic policies...
by pps43 on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @12:25PM
(#23392810)
Look at non-COVID-19 related deaths in a location with lockdown in effect, but with few COVID-19 deaths. Those should not be people who died from COVID-19 without a test, but if lockdown drives deaths up, there should be enough of them to be visible.
If you do it in New York, chances are you would be attributing COVID-19-related but unconfirmed deaths to lockdown.
* Select "Excess deaths with and without COVID-19" for the dashboard
* Enter "New York City" as the location (New York state as a whole shows a similar trend)
New York state was locked down March 20th. Notice the marked increase in non-COVID-19 related deaths starting March 21st, increasing steadily into April (almost 200% higher than predicted number of deaths). The tooltips also say that this data is still incomplete, so these numbers could climb.
Now maybe it's unrelated, or maybe it's COVID-19 related that was incorrectly assigned, but you seem fairly confident that it's unrelated to the other factors the OP mentioned. I don't see how you can reach that conclusion given the data available at this time.