Re:Google's Android faces a serious Linux copyright issue
by jmillikin on Thursday March 17, 2011 @08:52PM
(#2338853)
That's not ad-hominem; ad-hominem is "this guy is paid to attack Free software, therefore his argument is invalid". Merely pointing out an obvious conflict of interest is not ad-hominem.
The second statement is not a strawman -- that is his actual (implied) argument. Otherwise, the whole thing about Bionic is completely irrelevant. Bionic's license status only matters to client software if licenses are assumed to propagate across the library boundary. If running proprietary software with a Free libc is OK, then a GPL'd Bionic is no risk to proprietary software linked against it.
The claim is not that running proprietary software on a free kernel is illegal. The claim is that by linking to Bionic, which may violate the GPL, the proprietary software might become "derived works" of the kernel.