News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Decision: To continue working on the start-up or go to gr... by mechanical_fish on Tuesday July 01, 2008 @08:59PM (#233702)
Yeah. I noticed that it seemed to be a wiki, and was tempted to try it out... but I'm sure you can understand why I was reluctant to paste this giant glob of opinions all over your outline page. :)

Incidentally, no discussion of this topic is complete without an administration of the Greenspun test. Read the link I posted here, and the comments:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117378

If your partner can read all that and still be sure that he wants to be a professor... he needs to at least try going to grad school, because he's truly in love. ;) But I still recommend SF over Indiana, despite the fact that I grew up in Ohio and should really be sticking up for the Midwest...

Re:Decision: To continue working on the start-up or go to gr... by bkovitz on Wednesday July 02, 2008 @05:33PM (#234578)
Thanks for the passionate rant. I'm the guy who's about to make the big decision.

Something I found especially interesting was your point about unfashionable research not getting respect (and funding) in academia, even if it works out. I used to work at Caltech, and the biggest surprise for me was how much time the P.I. I was working for had to spend on grant proposals--and doing the political work to get people excited about his stuff. It struck me as pretty similar to entrepreneurship, actually, but with money coming from a very different source than happy customers.

I'm going to spend today and tomorrow acting as if I canceled my admission this year. Then I'll see how I feel on Friday.

Re:Decision: To continue working on the start-up or go to gr... by mechanical_fish on Tuesday July 01, 2008 @09:01PM (#233706)
Oh, and I almost forgot! An important book to read is A Ph.D. is Not Enough! A Guide to Survival in Science:

http://www.amazon.com/PhD-Not-Enough-Survival-Science/dp/020...

It's a bit dated, but it's quite valuable.

Re:Decision: To continue working on the start-up or go to gr... by sgibson12 on Tuesday July 01, 2008 @09:20PM (#233721)
Cool.. that's all very helpful. Especially the links and extra reference material. That's all we do these days is pass books back and forth. haha.