Re:Judge gives Sony access to PS3 hacker's PayPal records
by daeken on Thursday March 17, 2011 @09:57AM
(#2336074)
Another critical reverse-engineering case was Sega v. Accolade, 1992: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade
Re:Judge gives Sony access to PS3 hacker's PayPal records
by InclinedPlane on Thursday March 17, 2011 @08:37PM
(#2338817)
A more relevant question perhaps: is there a substantially different impact between careful clean room reverse engineering and simple hacking with public disclosure?
The key to this case was that Connectix had exhausted all other methods before resorting to reverse engineering; Connectix contended that direct disassembly was necessary, because they had no other way to learn the non-copyrightable facts and algorithms.
The holding in the case was that Sony's copyrighted material did not deserve as much protection, because it contained unprotected aspects that could not be examined without copying. This is why Sony's BIOS was accorded a lower degree of protection than more traditional literary/musical/creative works.
Keep in mind, Connectix was a 1999 case. DMCA implemented two 1996 WIPO treaties, and became effective in 1998. I've read through nearly all of the DMCA, and everything in the opinion comports with the sections of the US Code that the DMCA amended. This is probably the best case that illustrates reverse engineering.