News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by Luc on Thursday March 17, 2011 @09:44AM (#2336034)
Nice anecdote, but what exactly is prescient about it? Perhaps I read it too fast and missed it.
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by retube on Thursday March 17, 2011 @09:45AM (#2336038)
Indeed. A good yarn and an enviable experience, but not prescient of anything, or even relevant to the incident(s) in Japan.

tl:dr: nuclear reactors emit radiation.

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by Padraig on Thursday March 17, 2011 @10:28AM (#2336166)
tl; dr's rarely do justice but I think that's a bit snipey.

The point I took from it was in the organisational culture in the team that looked after the reactor. A macho attitude celebrating exposure to radiation does not inspire confidence.

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by ErrantX on Thursday March 17, 2011 @10:46AM (#2336226)
To be honest I think there were two seperate things there; the macho attitude to radiation exposure, and the mistake (understandably) made by a new team member.

The former is just a defence mechanism, probably related to them being in the forces where the alternative (expressing concern or fear) doesn't fit. But I don't think it would translate into "go on, lean out over there and you'll be top of the chart this month!!"

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by Padraig on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:07AM (#2336322)
There's plenty of room for 'respecting dangerous invisible shit that can kill you' between those two extremes of being a scaredy-cat and acting macho.
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by ErrantX on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:13AM (#2336356)
I'm struggling to see the jokey and macho competition described as anything more than camaraderie, certainly not an extreme or uncommon attitude. I don't think it means they are ignoring the radiation, just enjoying (rather than dwelling) on the risk associated with their chosen career.

The story conflates these two different incidents, but really they are unrelated. And if the takeaway you have is that they were blase about the risks, well, that isn't at all how I read it. Indeed, it was clear that it was taken seriously.

Steve just didn't have the same attitude and so quit, that is all :)

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by chadgeidel on Thursday March 17, 2011 @02:38PM (#2337393)
Perhaps I'm mistaken but "They would celebrate whoever got the highest dose of the week by making them buy the beer for the rest." seems like very good culture. The policy uses free beer to incentivize low radiation exposure.

It actually sounds like a fairly effective way to encourage everyone to pay attention.

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by patrickyeon on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:35AM (#2336449)
In my (admittedly limited) experience with managed risks (hospital staff dealing with infected patients and rock climbing being the two biggies, I guess), I'm not sure that what gets interpreted as macho attitudes is a flippant dismissal of risk. I think it's a much more complex interplay including elements of having to re-assure others that even though they may be scared, the situation is under control, as well as playing the same mind game with yourself.
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by sophacles on Thursday March 17, 2011 @09:59AM (#2336082)
I don't think prescient means what you think it means.

Still, it was a fun article.

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by retube on Thursday March 17, 2011 @09:57AM (#2336072)
Reminds me of my time at Imperial College London when I discovered that they had a FUSION REACTOR in the basement of the physics department- a Z-Pinch. I can't remember the details exactly but basically three gigantic lasers which zapped a tiny copper(?) target. Pulled like a gazillion watts, something like entire UK energy output for a fraction of a second. Resulting pressure would cause the copper target to fuse, creating a tiny, short-lived "sun" in the process. Very bright, very hot. Pretty damn cool.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z-pinch

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by mrcharles on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:04AM (#2336307)
Cherenkov radiation leads to some pretty pictures. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by michaelbuckbee on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:27AM (#2336414)
I'm sure it is because Hollywood set designers did research in nuclear reactors to use as the basis of their sci-fi set designs, but it's hard for me to think of those pictures as anything but creepy and foreboding.
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by bioh42_2 on Thursday March 17, 2011 @10:58AM (#2336277)
Can someone explain why the scram rods are not made to automatically fall into the reactor when power is cut?

I would image power would keep them out of the reactor and when power is cut, they drop in.

My ill informed understand of the Chernobyl accident is that specific safety measures had been deliberately disabled as part of testing.

Does anyone know why the Fukushima reactors weren't scrammed? Also, can you scram the waste pools?

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by ScotterC on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:01AM (#2336297)
They were scrammed. Immediately. What they're dealing with is called residual heat removal. Even though the reactor was turned off within seconds (same as three mile island), the fuel is extremely hot and takes about a week to cool it to a normal level.

Control rods are automatically scrammed by gravity when the power is cut. They are held by electro magnets on most designs. However, I admit that I'm not too familiar with GE's BWR.

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by wnewman on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:21AM (#2336391)
When you write "the fuel is extremely hot and takes about a week to cool it to a normal level," perhaps what you mean is not that the fuel is literally physically hot, but that the fuel is so radioactive that it continues releasing a significant amount of energy from spontaneous decay even in the absence of significant neutron flux to trigger further U or Pu fission.

When a U or Pu nucleus fissions there are several possible outcomes. Some of those outcomes yield radioisotopes whose half-life is on the order of a week. Thus when you suddenly interrupt a running nuclear reactor, you tend to still have a some energy output queued up to happen spontaneously regardless of any further fission/neutron chain reaction. IIRC, your "week" figure is roughly correct, but not because of ordinary heat capacity, but because of this continuing radioactive decay: the energy output typically continues for days to be several percent of steady state power output preceding the shutdown. (Which is enormously more energy than could be stored as heat in the mass of the reactor at any earthly temperature.)

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by ScotterC on Thursday March 17, 2011 @10:09PM (#2339009)
Yup. That's what I meant :)
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by brazzy on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:10AM (#2336348)
The Fukushima reactors WERE scrammed. The problem is that this ends only the Uranium fission chain reaction, but still leaves you with a lot of fission products that are themselves unstable with various half-lives. These keep producing a gradually diminishing amount of heat for weeks and months. Which is why you have the waste pools.

And no, you CAN'T scram those because it's not a chain reaction going on but simply radioactive decay - there is no known force in the universe which can stop an unstable atom core from decaying.

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by goombastic on Thursday March 17, 2011 @09:54AM (#2336067)
What I am not able to figure out is why aren't more robots or tele-presence units involved? I know a million gamers who would volunteer to do this stuff.
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by ohyes on Thursday March 17, 2011 @10:33AM (#2336185)
I believe the answer is electromagnetic interference. Reactors produce many forms of electromagnetic radiation, not just the ionizing type.

Also note, that machine vision was a big deal (for a while) in nuclear, because it would have meant that you could do without radio transmission, but even so, the robot would need to be really well shielded...

(IANANE)

Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by retube on Thursday March 17, 2011 @10:13AM (#2336123)
Access or dexterity issues?
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by tintin on Thursday March 17, 2011 @10:15AM (#2336131)
Re:Prescient Steve Blank Post about Nuclear Reactors by rbanffy on Thursday March 17, 2011 @11:29AM (#2336426)
That's one very nice story. Thank you.