Here's a tool that can help calculate useful exposure depending on your location/time of year. Doesn't take clothing into account however..
I list these numbers to give a general idea of the levels of Vitamin D that people experience without oral supplementation.
My conclusion was that too many studies were being done to determine the correct or safe amount to supplement rather than testing regularly to determine a safe/optimal blood concentration.
Very excited for good prospective studies of Vitamin D.
A bag of carrots wont hurt you yet an equivalent dose of betacarotene (vit A) supplement definitely will and is strongly associated with increasing certain cancers. There's a reason you won't see those on the shelf apart from miniscule amounts in multivitamins.
Nothing in nutrition exists in a vacuum.
Because usually phisiological processes are in some kind of equilibrium and regulated, so it's not straightforward to compare it to supplements.
My pale skin in the midday desert sun for fifteen minutes in July? I'd have a pretty serious burn.
It is certainly true that a few high dosages of vitamin D are not harmful. The issue is the negative effects of having too high of a vitamin D status.
Anyone taking more than 2k IU/day should do so after consulting their doctor or at least testing of their vitamin D levels.
I've been taking vitamin d3 10K IU/day for 10 years and it has allowed my blood V-D3 levels to go from 12 ng/mL to ~50 which is within normal range. The NIH recommended dose has been going up over the last 2 decades starting at 400 IU and now 4,000 IU as we learn more and more about it's effectiveness.
If you are rounding down your vitamin D status then it is currently at what the NIH say should be avoided. Have you consulted with a medical professional about your vitamin d status?
10k IU/day can be great when someone's level is 12, but it's not a maintenance dosage once at healthy levels.
"A statistical error in the estimation of the recommended dietary allowance (RDA) for vitamin D was recently discovered; in a correct analysis of the data used by the Institute of Medicine, it was found that 8895 IU/d was needed for 97.5% of individuals to achieve values ≥50 nmol/L. Another study confirmed that 6201 IU/d was needed to achieve 75 nmol/L and 9122 IU/d was needed to reach 100 nmol/L. The largest meta-analysis ever conducted of studies published between 1966 and 2013 showed that 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels <75 nmol/L may be too low for safety and associated with higher all-cause mortality, demolishing the previously presumed U-shape curve of mortality associated with vitamin D levels. Since all-disease mortality is reduced to 1.0 with serum vitamin D levels ≥100 nmol/L, we call public health authorities to consider designating as the RDA at least three-fourths of the levels proposed by the Endocrine Society Expert Committee as safe upper tolerable daily intake doses. This could lead to a recommendation of 1000 IU for children <1 year on enriched formula and 1500 IU for breastfed children older than 6 months, 3000 IU for children >1 year of age, and around 8000 IU for young adults and thereafter. Actions are urgently needed to protect the global population from vitamin D deficiency."
I have no doubt that the mainstream NIH advice is not optimal. The best thing for everyone to do though is not to recommend high dosages for everyone but instead to recommend getting vitamin D levels tested.
Vitamin D level blood testing is imprecise - I would not consider any one test of Vitamin D levels to be accurate.
This person's cited paper corresponds with the calcium absorption data that suggests around 8,000 IU D3 is where calcium absorption begins to plateau and more vitamin D leads to minimal additional calcium absorption.
Since I haven't been going outside, I take vitamin D 10,000 IU daily. You are correct in that one shouldn't just take the advice of random internet strangers - I should be more careful in posting. My personal experience with Vitamin D has been extremely positive and so I get excited about sharing what I know - of course I had to work and couldn't actively respond to this thread as much as I would like.
Things that work well for one person can be dangerous for others. It's fine to share your positive experiences, but it's another step to be recommending the same to others.
There are a lot of other factors besides calcium absorption to consider. In fact maximizing calcium absorption with vitamin D likely has negative consequences unless there is proper vitamin K intake as well.
Which is just what you did before.
Be careful of anyone claiming to be an expert on anything, especially on an anonymous forum - even if that forum has in general higher quality opinion.
And the OP does not mention Vitamin K2 at all. How does anybody who claims to have done a Masters on Vitamin D not mention K2?
Personally, I eat dark green leafy vegetables every day - one serving of kale contains 443% daily value of vitamin K and I probably consume 2-3 servings a day.
Most food we eat doesn't contain vitamin D. A serving of farmed salmon, for example, contains about 250 IU D3 - 32% of the daily value.
In any case, I highly agree with not trusting anonymous internet opinions.
For someone who claims to have done a masters on Vitamin D, I find this generalized statement disturbing. What skin tone the person has, what season it is, what latitude the person lives at, age of the person etc., are factors in how much Vitamin D is produced by the body on exposure to sunlight. I’m afraid I can’t take the other points seriously because of the brevity and lack of nuance.
My point here was meant to be about how this is essentially the daily maximum dose from UV radiation due to the isomerization of previtamin D into inactive isomers, and to give context to a dose of 10,000 IU D3 seeming large when it is half the amount a person might receive from sun exposure.
Can increased calcium absorption lead to kidney disorders?
This is my biggest worry when taking Vitamin D3 supplements, I have Vitamin D deficiency but when I take supplements it quickly reaches to toxicity levels (> 80 ng/mL) and so I have the revert to monthly supplement of 60,000 IU of Cholecalciferol.
PSA: I'm a dwarf, possibly Achondroplasia, but during childhood (4 - 15years) I wasn't categorised as such and my bone troubles were always attributed to Vitamin D deficiency. After age 17, I didn't have much of bone problems and so I didn't follow up on my Vitamin D deficiency.
Fast forward to age 32, I was diagnosed with Spinal Stenosis among other cerebral spinal fractures risking becoming quadriplegic[1]. So, if you have bone problems due to Vitamin D deficiency, please follow it up regularly, it's likely going to be life-long but taking proper supplements is better than a fracture. Also visiting a good endocrinologist to get to the root of Vitamin D problems is recommended.
[1]https://abishekmuthian.com/i-was-told-i-would-become-quadrip...
I hope you are receiving the treatment you need.
Vitamin D is involved with calcium in the body in many different ways, specifically I was talking about a measure of the absorption of calcium into the body from food as promoted by vitamin D.
Organ calcification is extremely serious and a very understandable reason why doctors have been hesitant to recommend higher doses of vitamin D, however most medical thinking about vitamin D until recently has focused on the prevention of Rickets, which requires only a small amount of constant supplementation (500 IU D3) to avoid serious effects. In context, 10,000 IU seems like an enormous dose. However if you look at the blood serum levels of people who receive consistent UV exposure, they have much higher levels than someone who is being supplemented with 500 IU D3 and no UV. So much of this debate is around trying to find out what the "optimal" vitamin D level is rather than what level is "sufficient" to prevent Rickets.
Seems like such a low effort, high reward thing to do.
Depending on the latitude and skin complexion that may be all thats needed for D3.
Re lux with full body exposure. I was under the impression it's an hour per day to get 15-20 IU? Either way it means exposing legs, hands and face to the sun which most people rarely do on a daily basis.
I’m worried about overdosing if I take 5000 UI and get a lot of sun.
Shots of 250,000 IU are given clinically and the therapeutic dose was traditionally 50,000 IU D2 weekly - corresponding to a dose of about 3,500 IU D3 daily.
I highly recommend getting tested for kidney disease if you are worried and get multiple vitamin D tests - the tests are imprecise but will give you a general idea of what your levels are.
In other words, 5000IU is much lower than what the body would naturally produce when exposed to sunlight for long durations in a day (assuming good latitude, sunny season, lower atmospheric pollution, around noon, lighter skin tone, etc.).
However, this is I think what you are trying to get at:
One particular epidemiological study stands out as a guide for what typical 25-(OH)D levels might have been be for our earliest ancestors.
Luxwolda et al. studied populations of pastoral Masai and hunter-gatherer Hadzabe, sampling their blood for 25-(OH)D levels and taking note of their daily habits in reference to UV exposure.
The mean 25-(OH)D concentration in these populations was 115 nmol/L, with a range of 58 nmol/L to 171 nmol/L.
This study provides a general framework for the expected 25-(OH)D level of active, healthy humans working outdoors at a low (< 5 degrees) latitude. Humans have modified their living conditions greatly from this model of ancestral life, leading to reduced exposure to UV radiation.
Define "full-body exposure", please? I'm not going to walk around naked outside in the sun.
However, there a a few things that are clear:
1. Calcium absorption from the intestine increases with vitamin D supplementation dose up to around 8-10,000 IU D3 daily.
2. 15 minutes of full body exposure in noon sun is equivalent to a dose of ~20,000 IU D3
3. There are few cases of vitamin D overdose in the literature - doses in the 1,000,000 IU+ range within days is generally where symptoms are noted - this excludes people with kidney disorders.
Personally, I take 10k IU D3 a day. The D3 is important because D2 has 1/2 to 1/3 the effect per dose in raising calcium absorption levels.
I would recommend this level of supplementation to anyone who doesn’t have a kidney disorder.