Unless someone literally burnt the money, it did some good.
Then again, yea, $2.4B is just ridiculous, wonder what Jeri Ellsworth and Tilt5 (https://www.tiltfive.com) could have done with those resources...
Building a bridge that collapses minutes after construction also entails workers earning salaries, and perhaps learning something. that still doesn't mean it's a good use of funds, it's waste. you want the investment to create actual value for someone.
Example that gets almost everyone: Space Shuttle.
It was supposed to be reusable space truck that reduces cost. It was several times more expensive than conventional approach with non-reusable rockets and shuttle. It was infrequently used. It drained NASA budged from anything productive. Even those combined manned+cargo missions could have been achieved cheaper with double launch. It was objectively failure based on the goals and purpose of the project.
They developed so much new technology and inspired people. It was simply great piece of engineering and PR. We learned a lot.
I wonder if there were missions that would not be possible without it (maybe the Hubble launch and the AMS launch and installation) though most likely they would be adapted to work without it.
Yeah, maybe they could be a double launch or worked in some other way.
So, I agree with you. It is a waste. It is a waste of human hours that was spent with nothing to show in return.
Hey, don't compare the fraud of Magic Leap with the straightforward honesty and artistic legitimacy of K Foundation Burn a Million Quid [1] which produced not only art, but also heat and light, and at a fraction the cost.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K_Foundation_Burn_a_Million_Qu...
The 2.4 billion could have been used to create something bad.
Unless someone literally burnt the money, it did some good.
Funny you say that because it is exactly the opposite that seems true from an economic point of view : if they burned the money, they would have reduced the money supply, thereby increasing for everyone a bit their power purchase. Whereas employing hundreds of people and buying resource for nothing is completely wasteful.The looser is always those spending the 2.4B of course, but the two have different economic impact (the first one benefiting everyone, the second one only a few people being employed)
Spending that money in any fashion leads to equal amounts of consumption and investments elsewhere (indirect spending). So we can discount it from an oppotunity cost analysis of how the money is better spent, leaving us with the common sense conclusion that investing 2.4bn in something useless is indeed a waste of 2.4bn's of resources.
In fact, burning the money is actually better than spending the money on something unproductive - the former doesn't actually consume resources that could be used better. Burning money is essentially the same as giving it to the govt to spend as they would be free to print an amount equivalent to the burnt resources while keeping inflation as it was before.
ah, the good ole broken windows fallacy strikes again.
Not like if we had spent that 2.4B on something else, those people who worked on that something else wouldnt learn anything, or earned any salary.
(Although maybe it is insane not to pull the plug once deceptive communication from the senior leadership becomes apparent).
I just view it all as a spot of gambling.
All the 2.4 billion sunk in to Magic Leap didn’t prevent any of the other things you mentioned from happening.
Could it have been better allocated? Perhaps. But who am I to tell others what to do with their money?
I’ll leave that up to the Snake Oil salesmen, politicians, and marketing-types.
Opportunity cost is real. That capital could have funded other projects. The engineers could have worked on real research. The marketing team could have been promoting something that mattered.
Yes, this is principally the backers’ loss. But that doesn’t preclude broader costs .
The resources were allocated to something fairly innocuous, rather than to something potentially detrimental.
Magic Leap developed an entire platform and also tried to develop content, not just glasses.
A lot of that effort was wasteful and mismanaged, but likely not by an order of magnitude.
I don’t think the word “scam” is appropriate here though. Just poorly managed.
Hell, Cards Against Humanity achieved more (and faster, cheaper) with their hole in the ground Black Friday fundraiser: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/27/503502142...
They weren't smashing atoms together to discover world-changing new physics. They didn't send people to space or develop some new revolutionary type of transport that could transform society.
They made some really average AR glasses.
Two point four BILLION dollars.
The Tesla Model S cost ~500M to develop from start to finish[0], so Magic Leap has spent 5 times that amount.
The ENTIRE Starlink satellite network will cost ~$10B total to develop, build, and deploy [1]. So Magic Leap spent a quarter of that.
Apple developed and released the original iPhone on a budget of $150M. Magic Leap has spent 16 times that.
These aren't apples to apples, of course. But I think it puts in perspective just how much of a scam Magic Leap is in general.
[0] https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/model-s-development-...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPhone_(1st_generation)