News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by mc32 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:24PM (#23342857)
But a private company can take action to impede everyone’s access to an official’s statements if they “suppress” those statements... that would mean Twitter has to allow anything any public official, at least in the US, broadcasts via that medium...
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by caseysoftware on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:12PM (#23343470)
You're getting downvoted to oblivion but I think that's a fundamental question in all of this.

Does a private company have the authority to impede access to Official Statements? If so, under what conditions? If no, is it "never"?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by gamblor956 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:36PM (#23343751)
This fundamental question has already been addressed by the courts many times.

The answer is yes to your first question. A private company is not required to make available "Official Statements" (whatever that means) using its own resources. The government (in the US at least) must pay for publication and dissemination of "Official Statements."

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by caseysoftware on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:29PM (#23344898)
Fantastic, despite looking, I hadn't found a decision along those lines. Can you give me a case to read? Just the name, I'm happy to do the research myself. Thanks in advance!

And to be clear, I've read the DOJ position asserting that "Trump's tweets are official government statements" (linked in this thread) but wasn't aware of court rulings.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by belltaco on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:53PM (#23345073)
There's probably no decision because it's black and white. For example, many media outlets stopped carrying full Trump press conferences live.

https://www.indiewire.com/2020/04/cnn-msnbc-not-airing-trump...

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by caseysoftware on Thursday May 28, 2020 @09:45PM (#23345440)
Please don't imply gamblor956 is just making things up. That's inappropriate. I'm looking forward to reading one of the many cases. It's always good to understand a) what the law says and b) how it's interpreted. They're rarely 1:1.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by gamblor956 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @10:58PM (#23345855)
West Virginia v. Barnett. Rumsfield v Forum.

There are more.

The answers you want are the first search result in Google and Bing for first amendment and compelled speech and are covered by the Wikipedia page on the First Amendment.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by caseysoftware on Thursday May 28, 2020 @11:26PM (#23345993)
I've actually read the Rumsfeld case before but I don't see how it addresses my question from above:

Does a private company have the authority to impede access to Official Statements? If so, under what conditions? If no, is it "never"?

As noted, I suspect this is not a 1st Amendment issue as the "speech" is present regardless and you have organizations, not necessarily people.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by gamblor956 on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:20PM (#23352754)
The Rumsfield case is literally on point: the government cannot force a private party to present government speech. I don't know how much more on point than they can be.

Twitter is not a legally recognized method of presenting Official Statements, as a matter of law (which sets forth the prescribed methods for making Official Statements). They have no responsibilities to present Official Statements, which means they can "impede" access to those statements on their platform all they like, in whatever manner that takes, from simply deleting such posts to providing fact checks to outright editorializing against the official statements.

As noted, I suspect this is not a 1st Amendment issue as the "speech" is present regardless and you have organizations, not necessarily people.

I don't understand what you're trying to say. This is definitely a First Amendment issue...even the White House acknowledges that this is a First Amendment issue. This order is entirely about trying to violate Twitter's First Amendment rights as a private non-governmental organization.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by caseysoftware on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:17PM (#23354988)
> Twitter is not a legally recognized method of presenting Official Statements

The Trump DOJ disagrees. Further, the ruling that he had to unblock people on Twitter established exactly that. He had to unblock people because he's making statements about government policy.

Therefore, them muting/hiding/blocking him is impeding access to official government statements.

Further, once they mute/hide/block some of his tweets, they're presenting some but not all.

They would probably be safer to allow all or none. This middle ground is editorial control over government statements which is a bizarre middle ground.. imagine a major announcement or policy change not being reported? Or actively being quashed?

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by akersten on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:15PM (#23344776)
> But a private company can take action to impede everyone’s access to an official’s statements if they “suppress” those statements...

Yes, that is their right to control how their website works.

> that would mean Twitter has to allow anything any public official, at least in the US, broadcasts via that medium...

No, they are not part of the US government, and they are not required to host official US government statements.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by gamblor956 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:33PM (#23343717)
Twitter isn't suppressing Trump's tweets. They're still publishing them...along with a notice that the statements in those tweets are lies, with links to sources documenting the falsity of those statements and the true state of reality (i.e., that mail-in voting is not unconstitutional).