News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Wowfunhappy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @04:55PM (#23342476)
To play devil's advocate, you can't do that in a public park either. You can be arrested for disturbing the peace or some such. So I'm not sure it's necessarily about private vs public.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by snowwrestler on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:40PM (#23343057)
You actually can do this in on public property; see for example the Westboro Baptist Church, which funded itself in part by winning lawsuits against government entities that tried to stop them.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by thephyber on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:42PM (#23344984)
But the rules for many public spaces and all private spaces are fundamentally different because they get to define who can use the property and in what capacity, or face trespassing charges.

I don't see banning a user from social media sites very different from exercising trespassing laws. Should Republicans be sheltered from trespass laws just because the owner of the property might not be a Republican?

Perhaps the best way for social media websites to avoid being is to more clearly define what content violates their ToS. I suspect most people don't read the ToS and certainly don't know how every company chooses to enforce their ToS with enough detail, and that's almost certainly the confusion when social media users complain about persecution.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by komali2 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:03PM (#23342585)
I'm not aware of it being illegal to stand on a soapbox and say racist things in a public park. If you're screaming at the top of your lungs, sure, maybe?
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by Wowfunhappy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:44PM (#23343110)
Well, yeah, I suppose it depends how loud you're screaming. I was imagining someone shouting as loud as possible, which you'd definitely get stopped for in many places.
Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by laughinghan on Thursday May 28, 2020 @06:26PM (#23343621)
Aren't you just talking about the volume then? You could be screaming the most wholesome things about unicorns and rainbows and still be loud enough to be a public nuisance, and loud enough that authorities will have the right to ask you to pipe down.

In America, no matter how big of a community mall, management can always remove you for good reasons (using racial slurs, even at normal volume), silly reasons (they didn't like the color of your hat), or no reason at all, as long as it's not for a prohibited reason (because of your race). Whereas authorities cannot remove you from a public square for no reason or silly reasons, only for good reasons specifically identified by law (like public nuisance).

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by thephyber on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:49PM (#23345037)
> Whereas authorities cannot remove you from a public square for no reason or silly reasons, only for good reasons specifically identified by law (like public nuisance).

It depends if you are reported and what for. American authorities have prosecutorial discretion, so they can choose to overlook the "wholesome things shouter", but may choose to charge the "racist shouter" with a vaguely defined law like "disturbing the peace". There are enough laws like "disturbing the peace", "trespassing", and "obscenity" which are largely subjective.

Re:Trump signs executive order targeting protections for soc... by epicureanideal on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:05PM (#23342617)
And this is where the courts are also going to need to do some work to decide what exactly is "disturbing the peace". What if someone says that wearing a red hat is "disturbing the peace"? What if someone says wearing an "I'm with her" shirt is disturbing the peace? Who decides when simply displaying a political view is disturbing the peace?

The left can attempt to immediately equate everything to the right of Obama with Hitler.

The right can attempt to immediately equate everything to the left of Reagan with Stalin and Mao.

Who is going to sort this out? Both sides might think they're being perfectly reasonable about their characterization of the other side. And if a judge on one side agrees with them, the alternative viewpoint becomes criminal hate speech. This is very dangerous.