News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by ken on Thursday May 28, 2020 @12:27PM (#23339165)
When MSFT bought them, I predicted they would pivot to adding features I don’t care about. I was right. They went from the best support I’ve ever seen (report an issue, get a personal email asking for details, see it fixed) to the worst (not touching a single feature I find worthwhile).

There’s about a thousand things I wish they would fix or add before this. They still don’t allow videos so every screencast demo on GitHub is still a giant GIF, right?

I used to like GitHub so much I paid out of pocket even when I was unemployed. Now it’s on my list to check out GitLab again. Companies don’t know when to stop. It’s like they created the bicycle and add another wheel every year as an improvement.

Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by tourist2d on Thursday May 28, 2020 @12:37PM (#23339318)
"GitHub is adding too many dumb features, btw please support my use case of having videos in my repo"
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by LordIllidan on Thursday May 28, 2020 @01:28PM (#23340006)
I've often wished this feature actually, especially when submitting pull requests, and you'd like to showcase the new features. I've often had to either embed a video link or convert to gif.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by toupeira on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:00PM (#23341027)
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by kisna72 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @02:30PM (#23340657)
I use gifs for this and they work great!
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by mikewhy on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:30PM (#23341445)
As someone who likes to do previews in PRs, mp4's are infinitely better than gifs. Better colors, better frame rate, better resolution, better size when you change any of those factors. It's really, really silly GitHub still don't support them.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by ken on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:34AM (#23346572)
Actually, my use case is clicking on other people's GitHub links from time to time and not wanting 5 MB of download for 100 KB of data.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by eythian on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:48PM (#23341710)
I have a video in a gitlab readme, it's quite nice to show how my otherwise quite academic genetic algorithm toy project looks when it's animated.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by arch-ninja on Thursday May 28, 2020 @12:38PM (#23339343)
Search has been broken since last November and it's impossible to select text when reading files in the browser anymore because they checked a JS-powered intellisense feature in. Now I usually just checkout the repository and use ripgrep to search for code.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by dstaley on Thursday May 28, 2020 @02:29PM (#23340644)
I search and copy text from GitHub at least a dozen times a day, so I'm not sure what you mean when you say search has been broken since November. As for the code copying, could you provide a bit more info on what's actually preventing you from selecting the text?
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by natfriedman on Thursday May 28, 2020 @02:39PM (#23340789)
We’re working on the video upload feature, which we agree is needed. What else would you like to see us do?
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by abhas9 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @02:59PM (#23341010)
I would like to see improvement in the code search results. Just yesterday, I was looking for some example code.

It would be a huge plus for me if I can sort the code search results and get results from most starred repos on top.

Currently, we can only sort results by time and relevance.

Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by ORioN63 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @04:59PM (#23342534)
The search results! And I'll be the first to admit. I'm not sure what I want, but what it is, is sadly just not it.

A couple of things I _feel_ (based on personal usage):

- When I search `import package`, I rarely want the package itself, but usage examples.

- There's a lot of repetition from forks.

Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by natfriedman on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:12PM (#23341154)
Good idea, I will pass this along to the search team.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by neovintage on Thursday May 28, 2020 @04:56PM (#23342492)
Agree with the improvement on code search results. Our team is working on it!
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by ken on Friday May 29, 2020 @05:35PM (#23355828)
Whoa, did I get Nat's attention? Prepare for a brain dump!

- Keyboard shortcuts: I’m always triggering these by accident. There’s no easy way (AFAICT) to block or disable them. My browser and OS already define a bunch of keyboard shortcuts. Please don’t steal existing shortcuts for non-standard uses.

- “Mobile” view: this hides so much it's nearly useless to me. (And the desktop view is a pain to use on my phone when I want to check one little thing.) 100% of the reason I use GitHub today is because -- by default, with no action required -- it displays the (entire) README, and the list of files. That’s what GitHub is.

- “?w=1” has always been one of the most useful features of GitHub. It’s completely hidden, hard to use (it messes up my browser history), and easy to forget.

- Releases/Tags: this page has only Next/Previous, no page numbers. If you want to get to an old release, you have scroll down and click "Next", and then repeat that dozens of times. “git tag” is fast (right?), so I’m not sure why normal pagination is missing here. Other GitHub lists have it. (Oh, I just found from poking around that "Subscriptions" also has only Previous/Next. I think that one's new.)

- “Issues" attachments: only a handful of file types are whitelisted, and it excludes 10 common ones I want to use (not just videos). I’ve never been able to figure out why. Is there some security issue we're avoiding by making people rename their .csv files to .txt before uploading them?

- "Issues" email responder: I see people send attachments here, and it silently drops them, instead of attaching them to the issue, or sending them a response that it doesn’t accept attachments via email. I’m tired of talking people through this. At this point, I wish I could turn off the email responder entirely, because it’s more trouble than it’s worth.

And finally, my Completely Unreasonable Requests:

- DOM stability. For example, when I'm not logged in, there's that giant "Create your own GitHub profile” banner, with the confusing “Dismiss” floating over a busy background, near the weird icon that looks like it might almost be a close button but isn't. I guess you have to always upsell, but nothing on github.com seems to ever have a stable DOM class/ID, even when there’s no reason to change it, so I regularly have to edit my user stylesheet to fix or block things I don’t want.

- “Issues" are the only major part of a GitHub project which aren't repos, so there's no easy way to back them up, or use them offline, or query them from a shell, or ... The GitHub docs always suggest some third-party API-based method for backing up Issues, and I've never gotten any of the free ones to work, and I shouldn't have to pay someone else to retrieve my own data. (The cynic in me guesses this is GitHub's primary mechanism for lock-in.) It feels like GitHub is a 2000's-era version control system, with an SVN-era bug database.

Thanks for listening to my ramblings!

Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by anewvillager on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:37AM (#23346586)
I want to search code with regex. You know, like I do when I clone the repo to my local machine.
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by hansvm on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:11PM (#23352617)
This isn't perfect yet, but it's better than nothing. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22396824
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by anewvillager on Sunday May 31, 2020 @01:14AM (#23367377)
Awesome, thanks!
Re:GitHub is experimenting with personal READMEs by faizmokhtar on Thursday May 28, 2020 @12:48PM (#23339474)
It could be a low hanging fruit that can be easily picked up.

I'm certain they have more designers or developers working on other features as well.

I remember a few years ago people were saying Github development seems to be stuck due to legacy issues and they couldn't compete with Gitlab in terms of features.