News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2 Hours With GarageBand for iPad - A Review and a Demo by freerobby on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:14AM (#2332338)
Two points:

1) I was referring to portable all-in-one units like the Boss Micro BR, Tascam field recorders, etc. Maybe I should have been more explicit about this.

2) Ableton is great for recording and processing, but for creating virtual instruments without external hardware, I'd prefer the iPad interface.

Re:2 Hours With GarageBand for iPad - A Review and a Demo by cageface on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:44AM (#2332465)
I agree about preferring the iPad to something like a Boss Micro.

What do you mean by "creating virtual instruments"? Do you mean presenting a virtual instrument interface on screen? If so, I do think the touch surface has some real advantages over a mouse.

I'm still not sold on virtual keyboards and drum surfaces on touch screens though. So far I haven't seen one I'd prefer to a real midi keyboard and drum pads.

Re:2 Hours With GarageBand for iPad - A Review and a Demo by freerobby on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @12:06PM (#2332573)
Yeah, I mean I prefer creating virtual instruments on the screen with the touch interface as opposed to using a mouse and/or keyboard. Definitely agree that MIDI keyboards are preferable to on-screen keyboards, but I do a lot of songwriting on-the-go so it's not always practical for me.