But the argument still applies then - if only one incident occurs where a catastrophic mistake was not spotted by the model failsafe, and if later investigations show that the mistake could've been easily spotted by a second human, a human will be installed as a failsafe for the failsafe.
I think the general problem is the following: if a human makes a grand mistake, it can usually be attributed to a temporal lack of care, or just random bad luck, or happened because the person was having a bad day, or... it is also generally understood that making a grand mistake will be such a shock for the person responsible that this person will most likely never make the same mistake again. On the other hand, if a machine makes a grand mistake, the intuition of the general public, trained by centuries of experience with techology, is that this machine will make the same mistake again and again and again, when prompted with the same input. If the model is not designed to learn from mistakes in production, this will of course actually be true.
That is frequently true. Take the job of a lifeguard for instance. A single mistake can be catastrophic, and yet we know that people have trouble staying completely focused for hours on end.
AIs have no trouble staying focused and they can be trained to spot drowing swimmers pretty well even on a crowded beach.
Having a human lifeguard plus an AI that alerts the lifeguard when it spots something suspicious could lead to better outcomes than employing two lifeguards.
I disagree. I think you'll see the same thing as with drivers falling asleep while Tesla autopilot is running. The lifeguard will let the computer do all the monitoring since a low false negative rate combined with a low incidence rate means that most bodyguards will experience the computer being 100% reliable for weeks or months at a time. In fact it's not unreasonable that if the lifeguard sees someone drowning but the computer doesn't register it as such the lifeguard may question their own judgement based on experience.
Well, that is kind of the problem with AI. How do you fix a "bug" (if you can even call it that) in a model you cannot fully understand? Do you re-train it on the catastrophic mistake and somehow give it more weight? How can you be sure that this won't lead to any problems where previously there were none? How do you explain to a customer that your model now doesn't make mistake A anymore, but now mistakes B and C frequently occur? The only safe bet is to write some auxiliary code, which first uses the AI as a black box, and afterwards explicitly checks the result for this particular mistake. If this happens again, and again, and again, you need a human to maintain and extend this auxiliary code and also adjust it to changes in the underlying model, at which point I am quite certain just using a person of average intelligence instead of AI will be cheaper, more reliable and more flexible.
Surely this will depend on the cost of failure, and the cost of the human failsafe.
Spellcheck in an email client helps prevent the minor embarrassment of typos and spelling errors in emails, and few emails are so consequential that it's worth having them carefully manually vetted.
In lots of business contexts, probably most, reducing variance is much more valuable than reducing mean expenses. Variance can halt downstream production, so the loss can be some huge amount of opportunity. And variance propagates through a supply chain, so your customers will hate variance in your output, as it may mean they have to ship the variance forward, which their customers hate. Plus if you allow your supply chain to get away with inconsistency, they can start to rob you with lower average quality and it will take you time to notice.
If a company has been bothering to do some process manually and they haven't outsourced it to the cheapest humans possible, then they care more about low variance than low cost. Pitching these businesses a solution that lowers cost at the expense of unknown high variance is very unattractive. Instead, you want to tell them "I can reduce your variance even further! Here's what that would cost".