Re:Tycoon Xavier Niel says he was spy who hacked ex-French p...
by philipov on Monday May 25, 2020 @07:48AM
(#23300114)
No, it isn't. It sounds like he's still the president, but he's no longer French.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tycoon Xavier Niel says he was spy who hacked ex-French p...
by Svip on Monday May 25, 2020 @08:00AM
(#23300167)
Yet, it happens so often, one would think it was OK. Like the Salisbury poisoning, where the victims were referred to as an 'ex-Russian spy', when he was really a 'Russian ex-spy'. Unfortunately, there are cases, where if one is true to form, it becomes rather a mouthful.
Unfortunately, I believe it is because what they mean to say is he is no longer the French President (as if 'French President' was a single term), and attach 'ex-' in front of that term. Similarly for the 'Russian spy', which apparently is also a single term, rather than two terms.
Re:Tycoon Xavier Niel says he was spy who hacked ex-French p...
by philipov on Monday May 25, 2020 @08:05AM
(#23300188)
The correct way to handle it is to use the word "former" instead. "Former French President" parses correctly.
"Ex-" binds tightly to the word in front of it because of the dash, but "former" allows "French President" to be the noun phrase being modified.
Re:Tycoon Xavier Niel says he was spy who hacked ex-French p...
by MiroF on Monday May 25, 2020 @10:17AM
(#23301357)
Only in your incredibly contrived interpretation of the english language. "Former" would be better here but there is still not any significant ambiguity as to what is meant.
Re:Tycoon Xavier Niel says he was spy who hacked ex-French p...
by philipov on Monday May 25, 2020 @10:22AM
(#23301410)
It's clear what they meant to say, but that doesn't make it correct. Just because someone can understand me when I'm speaking broken Russian doesn't mean my grammar is suddenly good.