News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: A Firefox add-on to strip Google search results ... by dannyw on Sunday May 24, 2020 @10:32PM (#23297145)
Google has a team of human evaluators called Raters that use a criteria.

https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/guidelines.raterh...

You can read about what the criteria is, but in short, it directly asks raters to boost established sites and downrank things like forums, personal blogs, and niche websites.

Re:Show HN: A Firefox add-on to strip Google search results ... by boardwaalk on Monday May 25, 2020 @12:01AM (#23297660)
I... did not know this. It's good to know that Google is also responsible for killing the non-corporate web alongside Facebook and Twitter. And perhaps more insidiously.
Re:Show HN: A Firefox add-on to strip Google search results ... by ajsnigrutin on Monday May 25, 2020 @11:23AM (#23301985)
This is (i think) also happening with youtube. There were a bunch of funny political videos a couple of years ago (eg. "Trump insult compilaton" etc., from different independent individuals), and searching for those terms now just shows videos from CNN, BBC, ABC, CNBC, and other corporate media houses.
Re:Show HN: A Firefox add-on to strip Google search results ... by IX-103 on Monday May 25, 2020 @02:05AM (#23298393)
That's a very cynical take away from a document saying expertise, authority, and trustworthiness are the most important measures of page quality.

I can see how forums would take a hit because users are anonymous, but personal blogs and niche websites should be rated high. Assuming the blog owner has some expertise to back their work, then just listing a relevant Ph.D. or other professional affiliations on the site about page would be more than good enough to fit these guidelines. This would seem to go more so for niche websites as demonstrated expertise should be more apparent.

Note that site reputation was listed as the very least important metric.

I doubt anyone else read all 168 pages, but can you direct me to the page that supports your claim? I didn't find anything that I would qualify as "directly asks raters to boost established sites and downrank things like forums, personal blogs, and niche websites."

Re:Show HN: A Firefox add-on to strip Google search results ... by tripzilch on Monday May 25, 2020 @10:06AM (#23301239)
> Assuming the blog owner has some expertise to back their work, then just listing a relevant Ph.D. or other professional affiliations on the site about page would be more than good enough to fit these guidelines.

That is pretty exclusive, IMO.

Re:Show HN: A Firefox add-on to strip Google search results ... by eitland on Monday May 25, 2020 @06:20AM (#23299713)
Obviously I haven't read this whole thing during my lunch break but if what you say is true then it explains a lot about why search quality has suffered the last ten years.

Forums, personal blogs and niche websites are often exactly what I want.