Re:CDC’s New ‘Best Estimate’ Implies a Covid-19 Infection Fa...
by jimrandomh on Sunday May 24, 2020 @09:57PM
(#23296963)
I'm pretty sure the CDC is just wrong about this, and the true IFR is about 1.0%. The CDC page in question doesn't have much of any information about their methodology, and the claimed 0.3% is not consistent with what other research has found. Given the CDC's extremely poor track record, I don't think it's right to assign this estimate much weight.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:CDC’s New ‘Best Estimate’ Implies a Covid-19 Infection Fa...
by ericb on Sunday May 24, 2020 @10:21PM
(#23297100)
Could this channel be politically influenced, or do we think this is direct from scientists? I have no idea how to evaluate this possibility.
Re:CDC’s New ‘Best Estimate’ Implies a Covid-19 Infection Fa...
by boomboomsubban on Sunday May 24, 2020 @11:18PM
(#23297448)
This is not trying to evaluate the actual fatality rate, they're generating scenarios for use with mathematic models elsewhere in the federal government.
Re:CDC’s New ‘Best Estimate’ Implies a Covid-19 Infection Fa...
by boomboomsubban on Sunday May 24, 2020 @10:16PM
(#23297073)
The CDC is basically testing different methods of creating models based on the available research. They note that these results
>Are not predictions of the expected effects of COVID-19
Nothing wrong with their results, just some grunt work that other researchers may use. It isn't worth this media reaction though.
Re:CDC’s New ‘Best Estimate’ Implies a Covid-19 Infection Fa...
by svaha1728 on Sunday May 24, 2020 @10:31PM
(#23297136)
Agree. New York fatalities are already at .3% of the population (estimating population at 8.39 million and deaths at 23k). Antibody estimates are that only ~20% were infected.
Re:CDC’s New ‘Best Estimate’ Implies a Covid-19 Infection Fa...
by elcritch on Monday May 25, 2020 @07:10AM
(#23299924)
NY really appears to be an outlier for the US. An IFR of roughly 1.4% does appear more inline with that for older sicker populations. There may also be other factors such as a more deadly viral strain, older population vs the rest of the US, genetic makeup of the population being more prone to covid-19, or differences in healthcare access and or application.
It really seems the fatality rate for covid-19 is bi-modal. Recognizing that seems critical to putting resources into finding the underlying reasons to respond with correct solutions for any given area.
Re:CDC’s New ‘Best Estimate’ Implies a Covid-19 Infection Fa...
by odkamkfn on Sunday May 24, 2020 @10:49PM
(#23297266)
Are infections spread out across a representative sample of the population?
Is the population of New York (in terms of genetic makeup, behavior, underlying conditions etc) match that of the rest of the world?
I realize that this site is filled with autists who believe they can solve everything with a clean, simple model (the less lines of code the better, right?), but reality is a fucking mess. All models are not even wrong.