Everywhere is my guess.
Some examples:
1. People go to their “local”. You probably already know people there, but you don’t when you first go if you are new to the area.
2. When you are out of town. Bars near convention centers can great places to meet interesting people. My local happens to be one.
3. When the bar has a theme you and your tribe like. It’s an easy way to meet new people you like. In larger cities, the bar scene is constantly evolving.
4. For live music. Having lived in Austin, there are great shows every night of the week. Yes, you usually invite friends, but there are some shows that I would not miss even if my friends didn’t want to go.
5. After a long day, I will sometimes choose to go to a bar alone and that is not likely to have anyone I know as customers. Sometimes I want to be around people and have a drink, but I don’t want to interact with anyone.
6. Same as 5, but I just want to read a long-form essay or a book.
I’m sure there are more.
Alternate theories are...
1. I'm doing it wrong.
2. I'm going to big city bars where people don't talk to strangers.
I've never been to a book club, but at least it's an event specifically for people to talk to each other.
Try sitting at the bar itself. Assuming you are at a social bar rather than a speed bar (i.e., one where they are slinging drinks at a mile a minute), a good bartender will talk to you a bit, and that’s often a way to get the ball rolling.
I will also add that some bars are more social than others, even though they may seem very similar on the surface. I don’t really know why, but it could be the clientele, it could be the bartenders, or it could just be that specified time/day.
For example, I've met plenty of neighborhood friends by going to live music nights at nearby bars and restaurants. The music was an "excuse" to go to a place I didn't know anyone.
In my city, there's also been bar nights specifically about meeting people, think speed dating but without the emphasis on dating.
I think this can be said for many group-class-like workouts though.
> Using hobbies is a great way to make friends if you enjoy that hobby
That is literally the exactly same thing as books club. Books club is not special, it is yet another hobby used for socialization.
You don't go to gym to meet people, because gym is individual activity. But people do go to sports clubs to sport a bit and chat a lot.