The practical problem with this is that services are at, what 9 in the morning on a sunday? The only communion i have any interest in taking at that time is with the cold side of the pillow.
But say the holy spirit [1] moves me to overcome that. Then what? "Yeah miss me with the biscuits padre, i'm just here for the bants!", not sure how well this is going to go down.
[1] whisky
They, of course, hope to "convert" you. Many seem to take pride in never "giving up" on someone no matter how long it takes.
But yes, going just to meet people is the wrong attitude, but better than not going.
(BTW. it's an old issue; there was even an old episode of Friends making fun of the conflict between joining a book club to learn vs. joining just to socialize.)
My experience from running a Hackerspace is that you need both. Time to talk about everything and nothing, and then time of focus for the people to actually practice their shared hobby. Otherwise everyone may just as well go to a bar for a beer.
Honestly, there's probably a sizeable 'market' for 'fairly broad interest group of strangers goes to a pub'.
In my mind a book club was a group of middle aged women drinking wine and talking about Fifty Shades of Gray. And even that I thought was just a cliche and not an actual thing.
Are book clubs actually a thing that people regularly take part in?
I've been part of several book clubs. It's definitely a thing people still do. But, it's not the social event of the year or anything like that.
Uh, what? I (and I imagine a good 50%+ of the hacker news readership, perhaps 75%+ if you exclude the USA) am never going to go to either of those without already knowing people.
> generic meetups, smallgroups, dog parks,
Places where you have nothing in common, so nothing to easily bond over (such as a book you've all read)
> volunteering, taking a class
Things where you should be focusing on something else, not socialising (such as in your ideal bookclub).
> If you're not going to read the book for a book club, it just seems like you might have better luck finding shared hobbies with people at a different kind of club.
What makes a book club different to any other hobby club? Or are you saying that you should only go to any hobby meetup if you're a "hardcore" hobbyist?
Because that leaves basically no way to meet people with common interests.