News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shut... by CathedralBorrow on Saturday May 23, 2020 @06:33PM (#23287175)
What was the "other side" of leftpad? As far as I remember, the broken system wrought havoc, not the developer who chose to withdraw his modules. I don't think the developer's reasons are much relevant when discussing how reliable their word is.
Re:Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shut... by dspillett on Saturday May 23, 2020 @06:52PM (#23287312)
The broken system allowed him to be a dick.

OK, so the is more to it than that and he did have a genuine grievance (I forgot exactly what) bit in dealing with that he caused a pile collateral damage for innocent bystanders.

(Innocent bystanders who errantly put too much faith in dependency oriented programming which brings us back to the broken system)

Re:Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shut... by alias_neo on Saturday May 23, 2020 @07:07PM (#23287427)
It's his work, and he had every right to pull every module he hosts there in protest. If this was a walk out or some other form of protest, nobody would be calling him a dick, I think that's a little out of order.

That said, the system is definitely broken.

His reaction to the Kik thing is probably where he was at fault, I think it would have been reasonable for him to back down there; companies, in the US at least are obligated to protect their IP in order to retain their rights over it (as far as I have understood from various discussions on HN), but perhaps the forceful lawyering got his back up?

Also I have no idea of jurisdiction of any parties involved, I just assume US.

Re:Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shut... by orestarod on Saturday May 23, 2020 @09:05PM (#23288161)
It's always safe to back down if you don't have the guts to go on, but you can't say it's a fault not to back down.
Re:Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shut... by ivanhoe on Saturday May 23, 2020 @07:09PM (#23287439)
> Innocent bystanders who errantly put too much faith in dependency oriented programming

and who need an external package to leftpad a string... the most fascinating part of that story to me...

Re:Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shut... by throwphoton on Saturday May 23, 2020 @07:16PM (#23287500)
> too much faith in dependency oriented programming

Which is why it's a distraction to even consider this particular person's track record.

Even if this same person pulled one critical package a month for the next year, the fundamental problem is still that the ecosystem in general relies on parties with no obligations to manage critical dependencies.