Re:Karma-rank (Pagerank for social sites)
by jsmcgd on Tuesday July 01, 2008 @07:09AM
(#232853)
I'm thinking out loud here and this has been mentioned before (although not really discussed) how about allowing people to spend their karma?
ie If I think something is worth 20 karma I give it 20 of my karma. If I think something should lose 10 karma I have to pay 10 karma to remove it.
It sounds scary as it could introduce a lot of volatility. The main benefit however would be that people are a lot more judicious when voting as it comes at a price.
I'm not saying it would work but it would be bloody interesting. Obviously there would have to be a source of new karma or else we would experience deflation. It could be trialled for a month or two with an agreement to go back to the previous system and to restore previous karma levels should things go tits up.
Thoughts?
Edit: forgot to say that removes the need for any potentially large amounts of computation to calculate weightings.
ie If I think something is worth 20 karma I give it 20 of my karma. If I think something should lose 10 karma I have to pay 10 karma to remove it.
It sounds scary as it could introduce a lot of volatility. The main benefit however would be that people are a lot more judicious when voting as it comes at a price.
I'm not saying it would work but it would be bloody interesting. Obviously there would have to be a source of new karma or else we would experience deflation. It could be trialled for a month or two with an agreement to go back to the previous system and to restore previous karma levels should things go tits up.
Thoughts?
Edit: forgot to say that removes the need for any potentially large amounts of computation to calculate weightings.