In Ramsar, Iran the background radition is around 200 mSv/Y (compared to a worldwide average of 2.4 mSv/Y) and _according to wikipedia_ this "high level of radiation does not seem to have caused ill effects on the residents of the area".
Call me confused.
Is the 1 mSv/Y total one of those made-up safety guidelines?
So no, if you got blasted with 10 mSv all at once you shouldn't expect to vomit blood or fall over dead, but it's still a sizable amount of radiation.
Also, 400 mSv/h is 3,504,000 mSv/Y (aka 3504 Sv/Y, aka 17,000 times the radiation output in Ramsar, Iran). Of course, one doesn't expect this radiation leak to last for a whole year, but the dose rate does matter. Sucking in 400 mSv over an hour is many, many times worse than getting it over a matter of years or decades.
Scientists suspect that it's wrong though. We have DNA repair mechanisms that may catch many errors.
The wikipedia article (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model) is pretty good.
The researcher involved proposed a radiation hormesis model, in which the body adapts to the destructive effects of radiation by upgrading its self-repair response. US regulatory groups adhere to a linear no-threshold model in which all radiation, regardless of how weak it may be, leads to cumulative damage. It's not a resolved issue however. The French Academy of Sciences & National Academy of Medicine, for one, cited the study linked below in an argument against the LNT model.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sievert#Symptom_Benchmarks [2] http://www.boingboing.net/2011/03/14/radiation-dose-and-r.ht...
Even if at 0.2 Sv/d none of that happens, you still have a very actual, massively increased risk of cancer and genetic defects in future children. To declare "no health issues", you most definitely want to stay several orders of magnitude below that
Well you could see this as a calm article to balance those with cries of the nuclear angel because lets face it, they sure are making something of this.
Where one side is "fire! brimstone! death!" this side is "lalalalala NO PROBLEMS KEEP CALM CARRY ON". Both are unnecessary, unproductive, and dogmatic.
This isn't a "(D) say -10, (R) says 10, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle" situation. This is engineering and reality. If the worst "nuclear" injury that has occurred is a dose equivalent to a year of background radiation and another of 1/10th of a year, the right answer is that nothing resembling disaster has happened, heck nothing you could even notice without sensitive instruments has happened, and it's not an "extreme" to say so if it's true.
Applying the political template to the story is immediately a fail, at least in terms of understanding the truth.
If there are no further blasts or fires I think things will be fine, but I don't know how much more damage the facility can take. Some of my friends and coworkers are evacuating Tokyo and I'm not sure they don't have the right idea...
Even just measuring that level at the plant is alarming, though it currently poses little threat to the public. It does raise the question of whether or not they have it under as much control as we'd hope.
The main information that concerns me right now is that there appears to be a consistent radiation leak of 400 mSv/h at the plant. While not Chernobyl by any measure, this is quite a bit of radiation, considering one's yearly dose limit is 1 mSv total.
This seems to contradict the extremely optimisitc reports that all is well, under control, and that no significant radiation leak has occurred.
[edit] One thing that optimistic reports consistently fail to address is the situation with the spent fuel pools. While not capable of melting down, from what I've read the pools are rapidly boiling dry and plant workers are struggling to maintain cooling on them. Left to its own devices the fuel will boil out the pool, light on fire, and then you have burning nuclear waste drifting directly into the atmosphere (after all, the buildings no longer have roofs). There is some speculation that the current radiation spike at the plant is not from any reactor but rather its spent fuel containment.