What I would support is tax credit: if you feel like doing a startup, under some rules, the government could give you a $100k tax credit.
Giving away $100k for people to put businesses into the ground doesn't seem smart to me. Otoh, each business is supposed to make money and if you don't become profitable, might as well shut down.
In any case, attacking this as a "socialist" idea is an ad hominem attack. Not that its the best idea ever, but calling it "socialist" doesn't detract from the merits of it one way or the other.
I don't see it as an ad hominem, nor was it intended. Just two disagreeing opinions.
Actually, this is just a recent annoyance of mine. In my country (Romania) the government just released something like this: they are giving away 10.000 eur to new companies started by young people, based on some form of contest (they read a business plan, etc).
This annoys me for multiple reasons, but one if very personal: I am disqualified from that contest because I already have a company. So I am literally paying taxes that are wasted so another guy gets free money from the government based on how good he is at writing business plans (or bribing).
What they could have done instead is say: all companies with young owners get a 10.000 eur tax deduction (maybe, for example, if they create one extra workplace). This way, you have to actually prove that your company is profitable, not that you are good at writing business plans.
I see how you're upset that "your" tax money is being given to someone else to start a business, but its probably worth noting that only some excrutiatingly small % of your taxes are going to this.
I think that other governments can and should learn from experiments like the one in Romania. But from a policy perspective, it seems like a somewhat reasonable way to spur new company creation.
If anything the cost of doing significant startups in the intervening years has declined, certainly for software, but also for hardware too. Apple had to build their own factories, even after they got venture funding. Now nobodies can hire factories on demand for your hardware.
$100k in the right hands would do a hell of a lot. However, the government isn't usually the best at determining the right hands.
The government doesn't create jobs, it just directs resources from one place to another.
Yes, it's socialist. The government doesn't have that money anyway, it's running at a deficit.
Imagine a national contest, YC-ish if you will. 500 businesses walk away with $100K each. That costs just $50M.
What would you get in return? You'd get tens of thousands of people racking their brains and being brave and innovating. Even if they weren't chosen, many of them would have a solid plan and go for it.
If we really believe that creating new jobs is our top national priority, then we need to find new ways to create new jobs. After all, that's where 80% of jobs come from: new companies.
I can already imagine some of my friends screaming: "You Socialist bastard!". No.
It could be done to reward merit, and it would provide critical support to promising startups right when they need it most. This is not about handouts- its about rewarding and encouraging innovation and supporting job growth.
Angel investors might be pissed though.