Re:In protest of the web{*} bulldozer, a response to websock...
by IshKebab on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:43AM
(#23256164)
Good list of Web* technologies but he is wrong about them being all on-by-default security risks and wrong about them being useless gimmicks:
* WebSockets: On by default but obviously useful and not that different to normal HTTP requests. Can you port scan with XMLHttpRequest? I wouldn't be surprised.
* WebBluetooth: Has a permission dialog. This is actually really useful for things like the physical web - you can control nearby one-off devices without needing to install an app or for either device to have internet access. Great for interactive art installations for example.
* WebRTC: Enabled by default but very useful for web based games because it allows UDP-like communication. Also obviously useful for video conferencing.
* WebAssembly: This doesn't let you do anything that Javascript didn't so he's just being paranoid that it "enables binary executables to run in your browser".
* WebGL: This one he has a point on - GPU drivers are full of bugs and weren't designed to run untrusted software. I'm surprised there aren't more exploits of this.
* WebUSB: Again, useful for using USB devices without having to install an app. This also has a permission dialog.
Most of these are because the web is now an app platform, not just a document store.
* WebSockets: On by default but obviously useful and not that different to normal HTTP requests. Can you port scan with XMLHttpRequest? I wouldn't be surprised.
* WebBluetooth: Has a permission dialog. This is actually really useful for things like the physical web - you can control nearby one-off devices without needing to install an app or for either device to have internet access. Great for interactive art installations for example.
* WebRTC: Enabled by default but very useful for web based games because it allows UDP-like communication. Also obviously useful for video conferencing.
* WebAssembly: This doesn't let you do anything that Javascript didn't so he's just being paranoid that it "enables binary executables to run in your browser".
* WebGL: This one he has a point on - GPU drivers are full of bugs and weren't designed to run untrusted software. I'm surprised there aren't more exploits of this.
* WebUSB: Again, useful for using USB devices without having to install an app. This also has a permission dialog.
Most of these are because the web is now an app platform, not just a document store.