Re:The pi is a lie… Happy Half Tau Day!
by jacobolus on Monday March 14, 2011 @09:50PM
(#2325456)
The context of this discussion was graders marking people down on homework assignments, not published journals.
You’re right that it’s political. Changing any kind of convention is always political. [By the way, I believe you mean pedagogical rather than pedantic.]
—
The use of octal or some other number notation system instead of decimal causes a dramatically larger conversion difficulty for unfamiliar readers than the use of τ does. It’s not a comparable distinction.
By your logic equating all such choices, no one should ever use a minority notation for anything, even if they think it has substantial benefits.
Thankfully, not everyone agrees, and sometimes our notation improves (A couple examples I particularly like are Knuth’s use of the Iverson Bracket in writing sums, and [] and {} notation for Stirling numbers.)
You’re right that it’s political. Changing any kind of convention is always political. [By the way, I believe you mean pedagogical rather than pedantic.]
—
The use of octal or some other number notation system instead of decimal causes a dramatically larger conversion difficulty for unfamiliar readers than the use of τ does. It’s not a comparable distinction.
By your logic equating all such choices, no one should ever use a minority notation for anything, even if they think it has substantial benefits.
Thankfully, not everyone agrees, and sometimes our notation improves (A couple examples I particularly like are Knuth’s use of the Iverson Bracket in writing sums, and [] and {} notation for Stirling numbers.)