Electronic signatures should have a lower level of trust than those performed in front of notaries and other officials. There is no way to check for coercion and many other ways in which the signature would normally be invalidated.
It's not an uncommon thing for people in Japan to be divorced without even knowing it. Their spouse secretly grabs their hanko for 5 seconds to do a quick stamp, goes to the city office alone, hands in the divorce form with both names stamped, and it's finalized. There's actually a separate form called a fujuri todoke that you can do in advance to block these one-sided divorces, showing that the whole stamping system is flawed if you need to do separate forms to block potential events of it being used without your knowledge.
Nearly anything works better than stamps.
They could just have you stand in front of the notary and swear (after the notary checks your identity), for similar effect and security.
The signature is only a small part of the whole procedure.
In most routine transactions, it really only shows everyone involved that This Is Serious.
As a little experiment, I once looked up the legal ramifications of 'faking' your own signature. Ie signing with a signature that's completely unlike your normal signature. Or changing your signature around every day.
Exactly. The level of trust of the electronic signatures should be as low as it can be, as computer security is really, really hard, especially outside of military settings: it should only be used to prevent the flood of login attempts and to allow to get or submit some less critical information, not to be legally equivalent to notarized signatures.
Unfortunately some administrations swallow the propaganda of the companies selling the electronic signatures and promote them as "solving everything" then they are "surprised" that the citizenship is skeptical.
And we know how unreliable "Certificate Authorities" are, and how hard it is even for big and very rich companies to maintain their certificates.
It's not that the cryptography behind the signature is the problem: it's everything around that is the problem that needs a lot of care.
Of course, you can only check for immediate coercion. You can make sure nobody has a gun to their head, but you can hardly check that nobody has a gun to their children in the car outside, or their brother that lives on a different continent.
At the end of the day, a contract is just a piece of paper and your signature is just some ink. Contracts only have power if courts enforce them. (At least for private entities. International law and sovereign entities are a whole other ballgame)
Covid is forcing many of these companies to transition to electronic signatures like Docusign.