News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Native desktop apps are far superior to Web/Electron by thethethethe on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:26PM (#23216078)
Seems like the only argument here is: “web apps are slow and use a lot of resources”

This isn’t a great argument by itself. There are many reasons that web apps are superior and more convenient than desktop apps. If this wasn’t the case, then why are web apps winning?

I don’t want to download and execute a binary just to read my email, make a video call, or read the news. Web apps are also cross platform. You can pretty much guarantee that gmail will work the same on windows, Mac, Linux, Chrome OS, and even iOS and android (with some idiosyncrasies). Web apps also update themselves, they take up no space on your computer, and can be customized using browser plugins.

I’d take these advantages over saving a few gigs of ram, which I have plenty of.

Re:Native desktop apps are far superior to Web/Electron by deergomoo on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:39PM (#23216169)
> If this wasn’t the case, then why are web apps winning?

Because that’s usually all that’s being provided? I don’t think it’s valid to say web apps are “winning” when in many cases they’re the only 1st party option.

I don’t have any figures to back it up but I would not be surprised if the native app versions of Twitter, Facebook, Instagram etc. see far more use than their equivalent web app versions.

> I’d take these advantages over saving a few gigs of ram, which I have plenty of.

That’s all well and fine until everyone decides to make the same decision, and suddenly every application needs its own instance of Chromium to run.

Re:Native desktop apps are far superior to Web/Electron by cm2187 on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:59PM (#23216324)
Don't forget that most users do not get to choose what software they have to use (think internal software in a big company, or you have to use whatever company x gives you to deal with their cloud, etc). And most software designers do not use their own products (outside perhaps of software development products). So there is a "good enough for the dog" element in these designs.
Re:Native desktop apps are far superior to Web/Electron by pmlnr on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:29PM (#23216098)
> that gmail will work the same on windows, Mac, Linux, Chrome OS, and even iOS and android

Nope. This is the Java Virtual Machine promise all over again. It didn't work. It doesn't work the same in Safari or Firefox as it does in Chrome.

Re:Native desktop apps are far superior to Web/Electron by thethethethe on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:40PM (#23217309)
Is chrome not consistent across operating systems?
Re:Native desktop apps are far superior to Web/Electron by pmlnr on Monday May 18, 2020 @10:49AM (#23223024)
Is it not. For example hardware acceleration is terrible under linux.
Re:Native desktop apps are far superior to Web/Electron by taeric on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:29PM (#23216096)
Objectively, web apps seem to be winning as they let the companies keep control over application and data. With a bonus that they can monitor/track usage.

That is, few, if any, technical advantages for users. Just fewer choices, as well.