https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/feb/26/bernie-san...
that part is absolutely a zero sum game.
now once you start adding in the rest of the plan the costs go up but that is a result of actual improvements in benefits (a good thing).
when I said worst case I was picking from studies unrelated to bernie's platform that showed an increase vs current system projects spending but it was modest. 700 billion/year in additional costs beyond what bernie has accounted for. and that is using the most expensive analysis I could find.
its probably not going to work quite that cleanly in reality. but the numbers are close enough that its worth it for our country to move to single payer with the additional benefits.
here is one of the sources I used to pull total costs from. most of the stuff I found personally ended up below their estimates. politifact's range is actually far less than the one I used by almost 20 trillion.
https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/dont-confuse-changes-federa...
--- this is a document i wrote up for my friends/family on the topic has all my sources and various other commentary.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-4-fYlRSRvtCar98APl6PzLL...
In most countries, most people are reliant on the safety net in the case of illness or disability. The French safety net is much more comprehensive, but the US has safety net programs. But they’re unevenly distributed across the country. When one of my family members on the west coast was unemployed, his treatment for his heart attack was covered by Medicaid. Most of the populous states extend Medicaid to everyone below a certain income level. Indeed, about 3/4 of the uninsured in the US are eligible for some sort of insurance, and many of them are eligible for Medicaid but simply don’t sign up. Some states like Texas don’t extend Medicaid to working age adults, but they’re in the minority of states.
The gulf between the US and “the other side of the Atlantic” is much smaller than it is made to seem. Federal, state, and local governments spend almost $7 trillion a year on services. We spend 35% of GDP, compared to say 38% for the UK or 41% for Spain: https://www.economicshelp.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/top.... There is a bigger gap between Sweden and Spain than Spain and the US.
Moreover, people understate the structural challenges in the US that can’t be solved by money. If we just enacted universal healthcare (Medicare for All) our total government spending would jump to 50% of GDP, higher than Sweden or Norway. (And that’s not even adding in free college, etc.)