Donny, Steven, Eric, and Bob have joined the Freeversation
Anon: "Hey guys how's it going."
Anon2: "Donny cheated with Mary."
Anon: "Okay, who said that?"
Anon: "Eric it was you wasn't it?"
Anon2: "Donny also stole booze from last nights party."
Anon: "I will find out who this is."
Full disclosure: I don't know how bros talk, but I can see Freeversations leading to confessions or straight out bashing. Best to lay down some etiquette for new users.
If people don't live up to our expectations, we do have some creative solutions for encouraging people to behave.
I do think it's a nice idea; but I would still be very careful saying anything serious on there.
Will you assign the same alias to the same user every time, e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identicon? That'd allow some kind of reputation system, at the cost of making it even easier to de-anonymize users.
There is a demo at http://freeversation.com/about/ but please don't excessively promote it or repost it to HN yet. We're not quite ready to go live. (Until this discussion hit the homepage, we weren't planning on allowing the public to access Freeversation.com until later this week.)
We will be applying for YCombinator.