Re:40-60% of the unexposed produce Covid-19 antibodies due t...
by user_50123890 on Saturday May 16, 2020 @12:52PM
(#23205060)
Yes, look at Greece, they implemented extreme measures.
As a result, they basically had no issues at all with the virus compared to neighbouring Italy and Turkey.
Re:40-60% of the unexposed produce Covid-19 antibodies due t...
by tripletao on Saturday May 16, 2020 @03:36PM
(#23206534)
And look at Japan, where they half-assed their response and turned out better (fewer deaths per capita) than Greece. I think most commentary assigns way too much credit/blame to the government's response, while ignoring yet-unknown environmental, pre-existing cultural/behavioral, genetic, or other factors. I'm saying this not to excuse government incompetence, but to counter the persistent suggestion that everyone could have the same good result as e.g. South Korea if only their government had responded in the same way.
Remember: the correct recation to a situation like this will probably look like an extreme overreaction.
There is basically no way of telling the adequate response from a complete overreaction right now.
Even if it turns out that in the end the IFR of the disease was just 0.1%, or that 50% had existing immunity... then that will only change after the fact what would have been the correct response. The decision needs to be made without that information.