News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by verdverm on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:31PM (#23199193)
What about the situation, "I paid them, but they never delivered?".

How would wage garnishment, as ordered by the courts, work? (This is the main one that needs answering because it is a simple example of the hardest anti-human problem that goes against core blockchain philosophy... reversing or forcing transactions)

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by erdii on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:45PM (#23199307)
Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by verdverm on Friday May 15, 2020 @09:27PM (#23199582)
That doesn't solve the general problem of complying with legal orders.

For example, how would escrow help with wage garnishment, suing a company and winning, or generally forced transactions by court order?

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by aspenmayer on Friday May 15, 2020 @09:29PM (#23199594)
Not who you are replying to, but I answered and addressed those claims in a sister comment, here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23199291

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by verdverm on Saturday May 16, 2020 @09:38PM (#23208730)
You keep saying you answered but you have not. That is very unclear and just throwing around words.

You haven't understood the idea and instead hang on to narrow focus around cash, which had nothing to do with the argument, because most people have digital money that goes through institutions. Using fringe cases to justify the common is the wrong way around.

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by aspenmayer on Monday May 18, 2020 @11:14AM (#23223334)
If your argument against cryptocurrency could also apply to cash, why don’t you also say so? My point is that cryptocurrency has aspects of digital assets and cash assets simultaneously. So if your argument equally would apply to cash, which is commonly used, then I think it’s worth pointing that out.

Also, I don’t agree that my writing is unclear. I find your dismissal unjustified by your arguments. I simply bring up a counter-example to your argument with cash. You saying it is fringe and beside the point is not an argument. To then criticize my writing is to miss the point I was making. I don’t find that you are debating in good faith when you make personal attacks on quality of writing when your own argument hasn’t been made or won.

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by verdverm on Monday May 18, 2020 @10:06PM (#23230624)
You haven't clearly replied to the scenario I presented and have rather used this cash analogy (and idea that if I don't address cash than the question is invalid) to continually deflect from from having to answer the original question and how it applies to cryptocurrency.

Cash is a bad analogy because it is the only widely used currency, it defines what we mean by currency, and it has always been a part of modern history in some form. Cryptocurrency has fundamental differences from a digital, public, immutable ledger.

So if you'd like to get back to the original questions, I'd be happy to continue this discussion.

However if your only defense for cryptocurrency is "cash does it too so we don't have to talk about it" then we can stop here.

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by aspenmayer on Monday May 18, 2020 @10:36PM (#23230785)
I’m not advocating for or defending cryptocurrency. I’m asking questions to clarify what it is you are asking. I don’t see why you think I am deflecting. Asking questions is as old as the Socratic method.

If you don’t think analogies to cash are a good answer to your questions, please restate your question. I’m not using cash as an analogy, I’m using it as a counter-example in the monetary marketplace that proves that different monetary instruments have different properties, some of which are inherent to the medium of exchange. I want to know why you think cash isn’t a good answer to your questions. I also am curious why you think cryptocurrency is a bad answer to your questions, if indeed you do.

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by verdverm on Tuesday May 19, 2020 @11:42AM (#23236076)
as expected...

I asked a question about how an immutable ledger, with public consensus, deals with the reversal transactions as ordered by the rule of law. Do you have an answer for that?

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by aspenmayer on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:43PM (#23199291)
To me that seems both too high a bar and making the perfect the enemy of the good. It’s asking too much of crypto specifically because the same complaint can be leveled against undeclared cash as you are leveling against crypto in your wage garnishment scenario. A hypothetical worker paid cash wages by a cash only business could in theory fail to divulge their full wages and thus fail to comply with a wage garnishment order. However, that is the status quo. To solve it is to solve it for all kinds of undeclared income, crypto included. For that reason I think that the current wage garnishment system is to blame for its own failings; it is also the moral failing or civil disobedience of the scofflaw which allows this situation as much as the existence of crypto. You may as well blame cash for the problems of crypto, and for the problems of wage garnishment evaders.

As to how you are making the perfect the enemy of the good: your complaint fails to specifically apply to cryptocurrencies in general or to any specific crypto for the same reasons it fails to apply to cash specifically. That cryptocurrencies cannot mitigate the market failings of cash is not a failure of crypto or of cash. It is no failure at all because cryptocurrency never sought to solve that which you perceive as a fault. The problems you raise may be very real problems in society, but they are not a problem that is in-scope for crypto developers to solve or mitigate. That’s more of a problem for crypto custodians and their customers.

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by verdverm on Friday May 15, 2020 @09:36PM (#23199650)
This is very confusing and I don't follow
Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by aspenmayer on Friday May 15, 2020 @09:41PM (#23199682)
How is cryptocurrency worse than cash for complying with court orders? If cash is no better or worse than cryptocurrency in regards to complying with court orders, then why single out cryptocurrency?
Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by arcticbull on Friday May 15, 2020 @10:04PM (#23199821)
Nobody gets paid their salary with cash for a reason...
Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by aspenmayer on Friday May 15, 2020 @10:13PM (#23199876)
Small businesses, strip clubs, public houses and bars, restaurants and their staff, handymen, private cleaning and janitorial staff, groundskeepers and lawnmowers, etc in every country in the world are innumerable counter-examples to that assumption.
Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by arcticbull on Monday May 18, 2020 @12:09AM (#23218223)
Many of those are fringe cases, and many more are moving (or have already moved) to digital payments. Square took food trucks, restaurants, handymen, lawnmowers, etc, on to credit card payments. Janitorial staff probably get paid through payroll the majority of the time.

Sweden even got to the point nobody was accepting physical cash in the first place.

Re:$14M in ETH stolen from Upbit were laundered in May throu... by aspenmayer on Monday May 18, 2020 @11:06AM (#23223248)
These fringe cases exist and are people too, not “nobody.” Cash still exists too. So do cryptocurrencies. Arguments against cryptocurrency that also apply to cash are obvious and uninteresting. That was my point.