Re:Nuclear Experts Explain Worst-Case Scenario at Fukushima ...
by erikpukinskis on Sunday March 13, 2011 @06:08AM
(#2318863)
Using "biggest in recorded history" as an approximation for "biggest possible" seems weak to me. Proper engineering will look at the numbers and account for events outside of the historically observed range, but within the probability distribution. The "biggest event we see in 1,000,000 simulations of the lifetime of the plant" is likely much larger than the "biggest we've seen in history."
Which isn't to say that it was bad engineering. Just that this being the biggest quake in history is not an excuse.
Re:Nuclear Experts Explain Worst-Case Scenario at Fukushima ...
by jeza on Sunday March 13, 2011 @08:14AM
(#2319017)
Sure you can't expect everything not to break when the mother of all earthquakes hits, though surely you'd expect a nuclear reactor to be failsafe in a self-sufficient manner.
Like surely they could generate the energy they need to keep the core cool from the heat it is still producing. It sounds like they are trying to do just this (not sure what the battery issue is), though if it were actually designed for this, there'd be much less of an issue.
Re:Nuclear Experts Explain Worst-Case Scenario at Fukushima ...
by idlewords on Sunday March 13, 2011 @01:53PM
(#2319752)
The earthquake was big, but in building a reactor on the PACIFIC RIM you set up your worst case scenario to cover a 1000-year event centered underneath the structure, and with handsome margins.
This was a contingency that was planned for, but for some reason the systems are failing. The measures being taken now are clearly ad hoc, rather than part of an orderly contingency plan.
Keep in mind that this is currently estimated to be the biggest earthquake in the recorded history of Japan. It's completely unreasonable to expect stuff to totally not break when the big one hits. If some reactors are damaged beyond repair, that's understandable, as long as the radiation is contained well enough to keep the public safe. After all, good safety plans will always be willing to sacrifice expensive infrastructure in order to save lives.