So what is hate speech in a way that can be automated?
Will that automated approach squelch valuable speech too? What if a certain disease impacts an ethnicity more than others? Is ‘black people tend to Sickle Cell more often than white people’ hate speech? Could a moderator decide that, given the fines? Could automation?
This is where a very loud problem is and this is the complexity you’re claiming is ‘simple’.
If you read it carefully, I just “made fun of” people who are unimaginative. Is that an innate trait? Should my content be censored?
Should a comment on a video of a tall person that says “how’s the weather up there?” be censored using criminal liability?
This criminalizes even hosting the discussion about what beliefs along these lines are or are not correct. Someone posts about their (mistaken) beliefs, in essence asking about a disproven theory correlating race and IQ. Other people correct them, educating them as well as any other lurkers. Should the sysadmins go to jail for not deleting the entire thread?
Being wrong on the internet should not be illegal.
There is absolutely not a bright line, and it is somewhat naive or perhaps even dishonest to claim otherwise.
Given that reddit is banning the word "retard"... the answer may soon be "yes, it should".
The conclusion TFA makes seems likely: these services will just err on the side of “delete first, ask questions later” to protect themselves from liability, making all sorts of legal expression impossible.
The current state of online publishing is really sad, and getting worse. Very few modern services used for hosting can be used to publish legal yet fringe or controversial opinions, which should terrify you even if you don’t agree with those things.
We’re moving toward a world where a dozen large companies will be the final arbiters of what can or cannot be published, regardless of what the law says. If you can’t see why that’s a grave threat to society, I question your imagination.
...and that’s just in peacetime. Imagine the special wartime requirements that will apply to these services if their hosting nations ever feel legitimately threatened.