News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Which way a wind turbine turns might not seem to matter, ... by scrooched_moose on Thursday May 14, 2020 @04:40PM (#23185104)
Preprint of the full paper here:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/338882074_Should_wi...

It's cool work. Some things I've picked out from a quick skim:

- Only the downstream turbines gets a boost, cutting gains of a pair in half*

- The boost only occurs at night, cutting gains approximately in half again.

- Veering winds only occur 75% of the time

This already cuts the gains from an ideal 23% to roughly 4.5% real world.

I don't see any treatment of incoming wind direction - it appears to only consider pure West to East wind with turbines precisely aligned with the wind. I suspect the effect would disappear as the wind shifted from other directions. While wind is generally westerly in the US, it varies a lot hour-to-hour.

Combine this with the above and I'd suspect real-world benefit is in the 1-2% range, at which point the added complexity of maintenance and production probably cancels out the benefit.

Not a knock on the research, because it is great work, but it is incomplete.

*This may be unfair, as it's unclear what affect multiple in a row would have. But the power production of multiple turbines in a row when the wind is blowing precisely parallel to the row drops off pretty quickly. Commercial turbines are something like 45% efficient these days, so turbine 3 only has ~30% of the original power available.

Re:Which way a wind turbine turns might not seem to matter, ... by csours on Thursday May 14, 2020 @04:53PM (#23185282)
A 5% gain is worth it when you have some severe constraints. If you can just plop down another wind turbine, that 5% almost certainly won't pay off. If you can imagine some scenario where you absolutely have to get the most energy out of the wind in a specified footprint, then it would make more sense (and cents).

As a counter-example, consider internal combustion engines (ICEs): they have had to get more efficient and cleaner, so you see more and more abstruse dingusses and doohickeys added to them. A 4.5% improvement in ICE efficiency is beyond amazing these days, and would justify well more than a 4.5% increase is cost for the engine.