Re:Pwn2own considered (somewhat) harmful
by azakai on Sunday March 13, 2011 @12:05AM
(#2318385)
The author makes some valid points. However, I'm not convinced that Pwn2Own is overall a bad thing, for 2 reasons:
1. It is far more public than bug bounties. The browsers that get hacked are in the public spotlight, and that can pressure them into doing a better job in the future.
2. The browsers that put the most effort into security - Firefox and Chrome - did well this year. The article and comments seem to imply this might be a coincidence. There is some element of chance here, so it's possible, however, I don't agree that chance is a major factor. Furthermore, if it was as easy to hack browsers as the article implies, you'd expect all the browsers to be hacked - again arguing against randomness being a big factor here.
Re:Pwn2own considered (somewhat) harmful
by f- on Sunday March 13, 2011 @12:18AM
(#2318416)
The key point is that there are dozens of serious vulnerabilities found in Firefox and Chrome every year. The availability of a vulnerability at an exact time in an exact place is not a good way to compare such broad trends.
1. It is far more public than bug bounties. The browsers that get hacked are in the public spotlight, and that can pressure them into doing a better job in the future.
2. The browsers that put the most effort into security - Firefox and Chrome - did well this year. The article and comments seem to imply this might be a coincidence. There is some element of chance here, so it's possible, however, I don't agree that chance is a major factor. Furthermore, if it was as easy to hack browsers as the article implies, you'd expect all the browsers to be hacked - again arguing against randomness being a big factor here.