Re:Nvidia CEO Introduces Nvidia Ampere Architecture, Nvidia ...
by fluffything on Thursday May 14, 2020 @03:15PM
(#23184042)
How come? There is a CUDA C++ and CUDA C toolchains available under a MIT license, large part s of which are contributed by NVIDIA.
How can they sue you for using something that they give you with a license that says "we allow you to do whatever you want with it" ?
Re:Nvidia CEO Introduces Nvidia Ampere Architecture, Nvidia ...
by Teknoman117 on Thursday May 14, 2020 @07:16PM
(#23186802)
the MIT license doesn't have an express patent grant. If Nvidia has a patent on some technology used by the open source code, they could sue you for patent infringement if you use it in a way that displeases them. What they can't do is sue you for copyright infringement.
Re:Nvidia CEO Introduces Nvidia Ampere Architecture, Nvidia ...
by monocasa on Thursday May 14, 2020 @02:00PM
(#23183046)
Google v Oracle is still unsettled.
Most other legal precedent was that it was fine to clone an API.
Re:Nvidia CEO Introduces Nvidia Ampere Architecture, Nvidia ...
by adev_ on Thursday May 14, 2020 @02:19PM
(#23183290)
> Most other legal precedent was that it was fine to clone an API.
CUDA is more than an API. It is a technology under copyright and very likely patented too. Even the API itself contains multiple reference to "CUDA" in function calls and variable name.
Re:Nvidia CEO Introduces Nvidia Ampere Architecture, Nvidia ...
by monocasa on Thursday May 14, 2020 @03:30PM
(#23184229)
None of that protects it from being cloned under previous 9th circuit precedent except maybe patents, but I'm not aware of any patents that'd protect another against CUDA implementation.
Using a branded & under patent concurrent proprietary technology and copying its API for your own implementation is Maddness that will lead you for sure in front of a court.
It seems that even Google understood that the hard way (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_v._Oracle_America)