News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit rolls out community currencies on Ethereum by intended on Thursday May 14, 2020 @12:55PM (#23181982)
Why are people accepting the claim without verification ?

I took cyxie, mentioned on the list and checked a few subs - they are not the top mod of any. It’s almost certainly true for all the other cases.

How is the claim “they control the news feeds” in any way substantiated ?

Looks more like power users playing subreddit Pokémon, and then doing nothing with the subs they are a part of.

Re:Reddit rolls out community currencies on Ethereum by dr_zoidberg on Thursday May 14, 2020 @01:29PM (#23182523)
You can literally go to the user page and see where the user is a mod. cyXie[0], who has been mentioned, is mod in hundreds of subreddits. /r/gaming, /r/pics, /r/movies, /r/IAmA and /r/EarthPorn are their top 5 by members, with anywhere in between 26 to 100 million members, depending on how much those communities overlap.

[0] https://www.reddit.com/user/cyXie

Re:Reddit rolls out community currencies on Ethereum by intended on Thursday May 14, 2020 @02:40PM (#23183573)
And that’s not anything.

He is not a top mod, being present on a mod list doesn’t imply control.

Someone of those power users was top mod for one of the subs I knew of - had 0 moderating impact or activity.

Cyxie is mod 14 on r/pics. Hardly a position of influence and power.

Re:Reddit rolls out community currencies on Ethereum by dr_zoidberg on Thursday May 14, 2020 @04:32PM (#23185010)
That depends on how much policing over the other mods (specially those above you) the rest of the team enforces. If the mods generally don't mess with another mods decisions, or if people don't complain (I've posted complaints after a post of mine was unfairly deleted from a sub) they can "get away" with whatever action they take.
Re:Reddit rolls out community currencies on Ethereum by intended on Thursday May 14, 2020 @04:56PM (#23185328)
Sure, and that’s a far cry from the click bait claim that “5 mods control 92 of the top 500 Reddits.”

It’s not even a statement of actual harm- just that in case the teams don’t check, these guys could be getting away with removing stuff and therefore exerting some form of control.

There may be some kernel, of truth, just to be absolutely and needlessly generous with the claim.

However the truth is not going to be close, by a galactic mile, to the worthy of the drama with which this topic has been en-robed.

I‘ve been a mod. If a shadowy mod had the ability to enforce their will effectively over a single sub, let alone multiple teams - frankly they would be amazing and should write books on their team management, work ethic and obsession.

Re:Reddit rolls out community currencies on Ethereum by lonelappde on Thursday May 14, 2020 @01:01PM (#23182083)
What is a "top mod"? Why does that matter?
Re:Reddit rolls out community currencies on Ethereum by Gaelan on Thursday May 14, 2020 @01:12PM (#23182238)
On Reddit, moderators are only allowed to add or remove moderators below them on the list. Therefore, the moderator who is listed first—generally the one who initially created the subreddit—can not be removed by anyone else, and has the power to remove all of the other moderators, making them the de facto "owner" of the subreddit.