News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @01:03PM (#23169022)
It's up to individuals as employees to decide if they want to subject themselves to this (agreed repulsive) treatment...what's with all these comments and sentiment in this thread acting like they have a gun to their head?

JUST QUIT already if uncomfortable with whatever a given job entails should that include perceived invasive measures ie - surveillance.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by Fargren on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @03:25PM (#23170734)
"JUST QUIT" makes it sound like quitting is an easy thing to do. "like they have a gun to their head" makes it sound like direct physical threat is the only mechanism of coercion that exists. These things are just not true.

For a lot of people, who have more expenses than savings and are not in highly demanded jobs, quitting puts them at great risk. They have a metaphorical gun to their heads. They might not die the moment they quit, but by quitting they are endangering themselves and those that depend on them. Their relationship with employment is inherently coercive.

This is especially true during a pandemic that's causing more people to be unemployed.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @03:38PM (#23170882)
"For a lot of people, who have more expenses than savings and are not in highly demanded jobs, quitting puts them at great risk. They have a metaphorical gun to their heads. They might not die the moment they quit, but by quitting they are endangering themselves and those that depend on them. Their relationship with employment is inherently coercive."

With all of that said: whose responsibility is it to avoid this type of situation? Is it anyone (or anything) but the individual them-self?

And should one unfortunately find themselves in this situation described above, whose responsibility is it to figure out a solution? Is it their friends and family who is responsible? Their neighbors? The government? Are you responsible?

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by curryst on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @03:54PM (#23171060)
I would argue it is the government's job to not allow businesses to impose dehumanizing conditions on workers due to the extreme imbalance of power.

It's probably not a risk for most of the HN users. Most of us are in high demand jobs, and we would simply refuse to work for a company that uses this kind of spyware. A lot of people don't have that option, because there isn't as much demand for their jobs.

Should we really be given that extra privilege simply because what we chose or wanted or had the ability to do is in higher demand? I would say no, it should be a fundamental right of workers in general. It's not as if there is some drastic harm that not installing spyware would impose. If your best means of measuring worker productivity is this junk, you're not going to last as a business anyways.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @04:24PM (#23171404)
"Should we really be given that extra privilege simply because what we chose or wanted or had the ability to do is in higher demand?"

So you think you are privileged because you exercised your option to decide and do what's best for you? Or because you have the demonstrable ability to make it happen - ie - learn a thing that is in demand? Is it a privilege of the ability to act in your own self-interest?

Stepping back, maybe it's because you have acquired cognitive skills that others have not that you are privileged? The mere ability to think for yourself, that's a privilege too, then? What about changing your mind, increasing your understanding of, evolving a thought...all privileges, yeah?

Perhaps somewhere along the line you have made a decision that was hard and required risk and sacrifice but that contributed to who you are and where you are today, was that pain and suffering part of the privilege? What about losing someone or something you love, because surely it's a privilege to experience love in the first place, no?

Is anything that makes us different and unique from one-another not a privilege by extension? Has the word privilege been used and abused to the degree that it means absolutely nothing anymore?

What about being alive...is that like, the ultimate privilege? So when all are privileged, are any, really?

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by Fargren on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @04:36PM (#23171554)
> When all are privileged, are any, really?

That's like saying "when everybody has money, does anyone have money?". People have varying amounts (and kinds) of privilege, but some have more than others.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @04:54PM (#23171730)
...and who has the privilege of judging others privilege?
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by evilolive on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @05:26PM (#23172017)
And you really think this is an honest argumentation?
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by maaanu on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @03:54PM (#23171062)
Yes, the government is responsible because it violates basic human rights. At least in germany this kind of behavior is forbidden.
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by chipotle_coyote on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @05:09PM (#23171858)
Why are you so insistent that it's absolutely, under no circumstances, the responsibility of the employer?
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @05:13PM (#23171909)
What do you mean by "it's" in this question - what is "it" you refer to?
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by boo_boo on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @01:21PM (#23169218)
You're out of touch with the reality for a large chunk of workers if you believe it's simple or even advisable for them to "just quit". We should be making the case for better conditions across the board, and this means not leaving it up to those in shitty situations to figure it out for themselves.
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @01:50PM (#23169543)
Who said it was simple?

But advisable, sure if you or anyone is not uncomfortable with what they are being subject to/asked to do as part of a job, YES, I would advise them to quit if deemed necessary.

Would you advise them to stay and subject themselves to they type of treatment they did not agree with?

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by boo_boo on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @02:14PM (#23169887)
Would you advise them to leave and risk not being able to put food on the table if they can't find another position? If there's little to no opportunity for lateral movement in their job market right now?
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @02:26PM (#23170023)
I would advise them to do what they felt was in their net best interest. Either way, they are making a conscious choice - a choice to stay and continue subjecting themselves to such treatment or a choice to leave and assume the risk.

Again, would you advise them to stay and subject themselves to they type of treatment they did not agree with?

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by Avicebron on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @02:42PM (#23170189)
By this time I can't tell if you're deliberately misunderstanding reality to virtue signal some sort of privilege?

But I will give you the benefit of the doubt. Vulnerable populations can have their employment opportunities gamed by powerful groups where they are essentially enslaved by their reliance on their paycheck to support their family, food, housing, etc. I don't understand why this doesn't register with you.

[dead]
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by Avicebron on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @03:14PM (#23170608)
"virtue signal some sort of privilege" - I'm referring to a particular "let them eat cake" sentiment I'm detecting by your posts. An apt analogy because it was a signal of her misunderstanding of the lower classes food situation.

"vulnerable populations" - people who are unable to quickly and efficiently move either laterally or vertically, in whatever industry they are in, such that they run real risk of losing food or shelter.

[dead]
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by evilolive on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @04:19PM (#23171361)
In a nutshell he says :

- from your tone it sounds that you have never been faced with such hardships and decisions to make.

- "quickly and efficiently" to me would be anything that would allow you to pay the next bills. Esp. since 78% of american workers live paycheck to paycheck with no cushion to absorb downtime looking for new work.

I'm detecting a bit of dishonesty (trolling?) in your answers too.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @04:59PM (#23171766)
Is it dishonest to ask questions, probe, push-back, challenge, disagree, whatever you want to call it? I'm respectfully inquiring as to what another human thinks (and that human was not you unless you speak for them?).
Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by evilolive on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @05:10PM (#23171864)
It sounds dishonest to :

1. not being able to empathize with someone who is economically vulnerable. can't tell if it's on purpose, or just difficult.

2. attach yourself to the definition of vulnerability. I just gave you one : people living paycheck to paycheck. It's a pretty mundane concept, and it's trite or dishonest to have to revisit this.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by panda-giddiness on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @03:57PM (#23171095)
Presumably these invasive measures were instituted after the pandemic. Employees didn't agree to these measures when they accepted their jobs, so of course they have a right to be upset with their employers now. If these measures are unpopular, we shouldn't blame employees for being upset; instead, blame the employers for dictating those unpopular policies.

Employees have little bargaining power here. While quitting is hypothetically an option (albeit realistically not necessarily), so is shaming. And I see nothing wrong with shaming companies for their stupid, dehumanizing initiatives.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @04:08PM (#23171238)
"Employees have little bargaining power here."

They hold all the power, actually, unless you are one who does not believe in the power of self-agency because perhaps you've already relinquished yours?

"While quitting is hypothetically an option (albeit realistically not necessarily), so is shaming. And I see nothing wrong with shaming companies for their stupid, dehumanizing initiatives."

Hey, me either, what kind of management culture even does this!?

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by panda-giddiness on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @04:55PM (#23171739)
> you are one who does not believe in the power of self-agency because perhaps you've already relinquished yours?

It's hard for my response to be anything other than rolling my eyes. I'm a grad student. If my advisor demanded the ability to surveil me at all times, what would you expect me to do? Quit grad school, throwing away my last four years of work, because I have "self-agency"?

No, I'd complain to some higher power -- in my case, the graduate student association or the university.

Re:Work-from-home boom leads to more surveillance by _curious_ on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @05:08PM (#23171849)
...Is your default reaction to hearing an opinion you do not agree with or understand to roll your eyes?

Thanks for describing what you would do in the situation. It sounds like you are the type who would accept it given the option of quitting or continuing, is that fair to say based off an incomplete answer? There's no right or wrong, there's simply choice in the matter we all have that power to choose :)