News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by vageli on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @04:55PM (#23159680)
Goodness, it seems your speech becomes more inflammatory with every edit. I'm sorry if I offended you—I think talking about the disasters are important in engineering—it's part of the process. In the same vein that FAA regulations are "written in blood". The deceased's weight could have been (and sounds like it was) a compounding factor in this event. It seems a process improvement could have prevented this, but we should avoid the entire conversation because it involved death?

edit: To address the content of another edit you made: yes, part of what makes HackerNews the incredible place it is is from people sharing anecdotes and semi-related stories.

I really don't care to continue this conversation, your hostility is unwarranted.

Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by dang on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @02:21PM (#23169951)
Can you please review the site guidelines and note this one?

"Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead." (a.k.a. please don't feed the trolls).

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by kbenson on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @05:16PM (#23159965)
I think perhaps you need to consider that how you interpret something may not be how it was intended, nor what it was meant to convey, and often the best way to respond to something that seems to deeply offend you is to first confirm that you understand what the other party was actually communicating.

For example, what you seem to interpret as people finding humor in the indignity of a botched portion of someone's funeral, others might interpret as a cautionary tale about what can happen if people are not careful about how crematoriums are run, and the pain it can cause to loved ones and the indignity it can cause to the deceased when the people shirk the maintenance required by the tools they use to do their job in these industries. In that respect, it's no different than a story where a cemetary did not maintain their backhoe, and the family showed up for a burial and the grave was not dug because the machine broke.

Given how the post was spawned from a someone noting a Crematorium Management System (and the lack of an open source option), I would hazard that a cautionary tale about what might happen if you aren't managing your Crematorium well is how it should have been interpreted.

[dead]
Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by kbenson on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @05:43PM (#23160292)
If you feel so boxed into a corner that someone saying maybe, just maybe, you jumped the gun and assumed some things that weren't actually valid and could do with some fresh eyes on the topic is attacking you, then I'm not sure what more I can say that is evidence more than that itself.

Hiding behind a blanket of being "for human dignity" is no defense when your actions don't actually help that cause in any way. In fact, I think the original comment you've belittles so much does more for actually helping human dignity than anything you've said, as it outlines a real consequence to real people for others not taking into account what happens when they shirk their duties. The lip service you provide to that ideal doesn't come close to doing as much, but given your lack of evidence for your behavior, I think you know that deep down, and that's why you're attacking everyone's motivations and character (without cause).

In any case, I think you'll find that attempting to win an argument through stoking people's indignity when there wasn't anything to indignant about is a losing argument here. You could try actually explaining why you think the original comment deserves your ire (that is, in more detail than something along the lines of "that's mean to people in a way that is so self-evident I refuse to explain it") rather than attacking everyone that asks you to explain it as too coldly analytical. Just because something's a feeling doesn't mean there shouldn't be a reason behind that feeling, at least if you plan to impose that behavior upon other people.

> At a meta level, if our conversation doesn’t make clear the very problem I’m trying to communicate to you in regard to engineering’s relationship with humanity

If by communicate you mean vilify without explanation...

Put simply, the engineering discussion needs to be had. Just because you wrongly assume it means people don't have feelings on the subject doesn't mean there isn't a need for the discussion, whether you find it hard to stomach or not. People are hurt by systems all the time, and discussing how and why this happens helps those systems hurt less people. Stopping those conversations because you think it causes indignity so someone who was defined with all manner of anonymity doesn't help anyone. Not the people in question (which nobody here knows who they are), nor other people in similar situations, nor the engineers who might have ways of preventing some occurrences of the problem in the future.

[dead]
Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by kbenson on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @06:00PM (#23160502)
It's all in how you interpret it. Let me show you some other interpretations of what you read.

> 1) Unfortunately, someone took a conversation about a purchase request as a chance to speak to [me] in a personal capacity

"I was checking in on different departments, to make sure everyting was running smoothly, but got drawn into a non-work discussion I didn't really expect or have a lot of time for, but that's okay, he's a nice guy."

> 2) Now that I live with the story, I’ve been waiting for a chance to share it so I don’t have to live with it any more.

"Now that someone mentions some software that would possibly have prevented the exact problem the person related to me, I think it's relevant to share.

> 3) Someone finally mentioned crematoria! Yes! Gather around, fellow engineers, to dissect a Therac none of you will ever interact with. By the way, the guy was half burned and fat. Sucks, right?

"And the implicit moral of my story is that these weird and esoteric systems the top level comment mentioned and wished there were open source versions for because they all require windows do have consequences, and do need options."

Or, you could just assume the person was like "ha ha dead people and fire" and assume everyone that asks you why you're upset is trying to curry favor with some weird set of tech moguls or something.

Edit:

> If it’s a problem that I care about those things, then, well, we are going to disagree.

Caring is not the problem, caring is laudable. Seeing those things where they don't exist, that's not. I think you're keying off some words in the post and letting that set a state of mind that colored the rest of what you read. To me, that exchange was a moment of "aw, that sucks. I feel bad for everyone involved" on the part of both parties in the conversation. Relating that itself is not bad.

In any case, we've gotten to the point where I actually got to see your reasoning to some minimal degree, and it's about what I thought (a gross misinterpretation to my eyes). I've addressed that here and before, and I'll let you have the last word.

Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by dang on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @02:20PM (#23169949)
Can you please review the site guidelines and note this one?

"Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead." (a.k.a. please don't feed the trolls).

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by kbenson on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @05:24PM (#23171994)
I think that's a subjective line. It's easy enough to get in a mindset that anyone that you disagree with to an extreme degree is just trolling, but I think we're all better off not assuming that too early. I was attempting to redirect the discussion in a productive direction, and did stop after it became abundantly clear that wasn't going to happen, but I'll readily admit in hindsight it probably went a comment or two farther than it needed.

I can't reply it won't happen again (I'm an optimist at heart, which is part of the problem in this case), but I can say I do try hard and I think mostly succeed in reigning those impulses in, and I like to think it's somewhat rare (at least to this degree).

Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by dang on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @07:30PM (#23173115)
I agree completely. Nicely written.
[dead]
Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by youdonthavekids on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @08:31PM (#23161967)
Not a big fan of your comments but I really don't like the fact you're being censored.
Re:Linux is Most Used OS in Microsoft Azure – over 50 percen... by dang on Wednesday May 13, 2020 @02:20PM (#23169947)
You can see all [dead] and [flagged] comments by setting 'showdead' to 'yes' in your profile. Nothing is censored permanently on HN, except when the author makes a request to have their own stuff deleted and we can do that without damaging the thread for anyone else.