News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan's Strict Building Codes Saved Lives by jshen on Friday March 11, 2011 @08:39PM (#2315673)
Reading a book is a large investment of time. You have to give me something to make me think it's worthwhile. This narrative of violence doesn't make any sense to me. Should we use violence to enforce contract law? Should we use nuclear power, and if so should we use violence to raise taxes to manage nuclear power plants? Should we use violence to prevent child labor?

I'm still trying to find some core libertarian values that I can understand and is consistent. I'm not motivated to spend hours reading a book without that.

Re:Japan's Strict Building Codes Saved Lives by solson on Friday March 11, 2011 @09:55PM (#2315830)
Are you looking for some universal value? How about, "We should not use violence or coercion against peaceful people, and we must intelligently and slowly begin to work toward that goal. Violence is not an acceptable answer to our problems." But you are clearly an intelligent person, and you know that life is nuanced. Social interactions aren't 100% consistent all the time. But this is clearly an ideal we could work toward.

I'm starting to think I'm feeding a troll. I feel like you are just trying to get me to say, something like "Child labor should be legal." But I'm not saying that, I'm saying that the answer can be solved - over time - without violence.

How could you learn about a thing without investing some time?

A few reasons why reading the book would be worth your while:

1. Why do you believe violence is a necessary ingredient for the achievement of the above goals?

2. Is working toward a less violent world worthwhile, even if it seems remote at this moment?

3. To gain understanding. Even if you're sure there is no possible way you'd agree with anything you'll read in such a book, you would learn about the philosophy that is embraced by an estimated 10-20% of the American public, not enough to "win" an election, but certainly enough to lose one if you piss them off.

Go ahead and have the last word...

Re:Japan's Strict Building Codes Saved Lives by jshen on Friday March 11, 2011 @10:27PM (#2315882)
I've asked a few simple questions and haven't gotten an answer. How does that make me a troll?

'I feel like you are just trying to get me to say, something like "Child labor should be legal."'

No, I'm trying to get you to explain how you prevent it without violence.

"I'm saying that the answer can be solved - over time - without violence."

How?

"How could you learn about a thing without investing some time?"

There is an effectively infinite number of things I could learn about, sadly I have a small finite amount of time. This makes me picky about what I spend time on.

"Why do you believe violence is a necessary ingredient for the achievement of the above goals?"

For many reasons. One, it's in individuals personal interest to take advantage of others. This could be child labor, pollution, outright fraud, breaking a contract, etc. How would you deal with these? I still don't know. Two, some people are plain crazy, and do stupid things. And that still leaves the more complicated issues like water rights. How does a libertarian system deal with water flowing throw a river on someones property? Can the person upstream suck it out or build a damn? Can they dump pollutants into it? How does a libertarian system resolve that, and more importantly how would you enforce the resolution?

"Is working toward a less violent world worthwhile, even if it seems remote at this moment?"

This doesn't mean anything. How do you deal with situations where one persons interests and liberty are in conflict with another persons interests and liberty?